Has a tax audit treated your cash desk balance as salary? First reconstruct the cash flows and check the reasonable balance. In two independent disputes, when earlier orders were executed, the reasonable balance was adjusted and the income tax and the fine were reduced along with it. So set out the grounds of your appeal with a specific calculation and documents.
To assess the cash balance calculation and the grounds for an appeal, contact us: ai.eaudit.ge/dava or by phone: 598 21 27 01.
To determine the reasonable balance, Annex No. 9 uses the cash receipts and cash disbursements of the month concerned. It also sets the thresholds for its application, special cases and the taxation period. The rule attributing the amount to the director is also conditional: the methodology provides for the possibility that another identifiable responsible person exists.
The main practical step is this: compare the balance adopted by the audit with your own monthly calculation and with the evidence for each difference. Below we look at two outcomes of recalculations that were carried out, two issues sent back for further examination and two rejections.
Recalculating the reasonable balance reduced the tax and the fine
In two independent disputes, the execution of earlier orders changed the outcome. In one, the audit was instructed to check the reasonable balance in accordance with Annex No. 9. In the recalculation it took into account 10% of cash disbursements and 10% of cash receipts, which reduced the income tax and the related fine.
In the second case, with the taxpayer's participation and on the basis of additional documents, the accounts payable and the related payments were clarified. The reasonable cash balance was adjusted as well; the recalculation carried out reduced the income tax and the fine. Here the outcome rested on clarifying, together, the movements confirmed by documents and the reasonable balance.
These reductions were obtained when earlier orders were executed; the appeals filed later against the results of the recalculation were rejected. The author's recommendation is that, when appealing, you state exactly which receipt, disbursement or reasonable balance should be changed and attach your own calculation.
What counts as a cash desk and a cash balance
For the methodology, a cash desk is any place where cash is kept: a safe, a drawer, a cash point, the pocket or wallet of an accountable person. A bank account is not included in this definition. Check every place where cash is kept, as well as the data on the accountable person.
The cash balance is the amount that, at the end of each calendar month, exists according to the accounting records or is deemed to exist. It may include cash calculated by the indirect method. Therefore, both the amount recorded in the documents and the assumptions by which the audit deemed another amount to be in the cash desk need to be checked.
The reasonable part of the balance is the part that has to be kept because of the specifics of the activity, the business transaction or the business plan. An amount above the reasonable level is unreasonable. Next, check how the audit applied the methodology's formula to these amounts.
The static balance is the part of the unreasonable balance at the beginning of the period that is recorded, without any decrease, in the unreasonable balance at the end of the period. The fictitious balance is the part of the unreasonable balance in the month of the inventory count that likewise remains undiminished until the end of the period. For these two balances, the methodology sets different taxation periods.
When Annex No. 9 is mandatory
Under Article 4, the methodology must be applied to a person who has a recorded cash balance where the base subject to income tax, calculated under the same methodology, reaches the relevant threshold: at least GEL 1 000 for the small category, GEL 10 000 for the medium category and GEL 100 000 for the large category.
These thresholds refer to the taxable base calculated under the methodology, not simply to the amount recorded in the cash desk. The text uses the taxpayer size category; it does not follow from this wording that it is automatically the same as the small business tax status.
The same article also contains exceptions to its application. They cover the relevant activities of the listed financial entities, insurance activities, lotteries and games defined by law, and the relevant activities of a registered payment service provider. So the first question to settle is whether the methodology applies at all, and only then the application of a particular formula.
Which movements are included in the calculation
A cash disbursement is an amount that has left the cash desk or is deemed to have left it. The methodology includes in it the repayment of accounts payable, advances, salary, dividends, loans, interest, royalties, other documented expenses and amounts deemed paid under the relevant rules. Expenses or benefits that have been taxed, and expenses calculated by the indirect method, are also taken into account.
A cash receipt is an amount that has come into the cash desk or is deemed to have come in. It may be payment for goods or services, an advance, dividends, interest, royalties, a guarantee or deposit amount, a loan, other income, and also income calculated by the indirect method. Taking only sales proceeds does not fully reflect this definition.
Under Article 4.3 of Annex No. 9, a transaction that changes the balance must take place within the period under audit. For it to be taken into account, appropriate information or documentation that the authority finds credible must be submitted before the audit is completed. In the two disputes discussed, the authority nevertheless later gave the taxpayer 15 calendar days from the delivery of the order to submit evidence. The author's recommendation: do not build your defence on this additional opportunity — submit the documents while the audit is in progress.
The reasonable balance formula
Where a month has both cash receipts and cash disbursements, Article 5 states directly:
"If, during a calendar month, a taxpayer has both cash receipts and cash disbursements, the reasonable balance shall be deemed to be 10% of the taxpayer's cash disbursements during that calendar month plus 10% of the cash receipts during that calendar month, and any amount above this level shall be deemed an unreasonable balance."
Other cases have separate rules. Where, because of the specifics of the activity, there are only cash receipts, 10% of them is used; where there are only cash disbursements, 10% of the disbursements. These are the rules of Articles 6 and 7. Choosing the formula must be preceded by establishing what was treated as receipts and disbursements under the definitions of this methodology.
Where expenses are paid from the cash desks of territorially separate facilities, Article 8 provides for the reasonable balance to be determined separately for each. Under Article 9, if during the period under audit the balance established by an inventory count exceeds the reasonable balance of any month, the amount established by the inventory count is deemed reasonable for that month. Compare the calculation with the result of the cash desk inventory count as well.
Whose income the amount is and in which period
Article 10 classifies the unreasonable balance of the last month of the period as salary paid to the director, if there is no other identifiable responsible person. In the example in Article 10, the tax is calculated as follows: unreasonable balance ÷ 0,8 × 0,2 — the balance is treated as net salary received in hand. Under Article 11, the static balance is attributed to the very first month and, to avoid double taxation, the unreasonable balance at the end of the period is reduced by its amount.
Under Article 12, the part of the fictitious balance that exceeds the static balance is classified as salary in the month of the cash inventory count. In this case too, the methodology provides for the final unreasonable balance to be reduced by the amount of the fictitious balance.
Article 73, paragraph 4 of the Code states: "If any amount is used in the interests of a particular person, that amount shall be deemed to have been received by that person." Under subparagraph "ბ" of paragraph 9, the authority has the right "taking into account the form and substance of a business transaction, to change its classification if the form of the transaction does not correspond to its substance".
The first paragraph of Article 101 treats remuneration and benefits received from employment as salary. Subparagraph "ა" of the first paragraph of Article 154, subject to its own exceptions, requires the payer of salary to withhold the tax; subparagraphs "ა" and "ბ" of paragraph 2 place liability on the payer of the income. A distinction must therefore be drawn between the person for whose benefit the amount was treated as received and the person obliged to pay the tax at source.
Attach evidence of the movement of the money
In two independent disputes, the clarification of the balance was linked to the examination of evidence of the cash flows. In one, the authority required confirmation of cash being paid into a bank account and of its subsequent placement or use in the business. In the other, it instructed that the evidence of expenses be examined in order to clarify the cash balance, including the material already attached to the appeal.
In both cases the audit was instructed to examine the new material and, where there were proper grounds, to adjust the liabilities. An instruction to re-examine does not mean a final reduction — the outcome depends on the recalculation.
What did not serve as grounds for changing the assessment
In two other independent disputes, the explanations and the material submitted did not establish grounds for reducing the balance. In one, the original disbursement of the loan referred to and the actual incurring of the expenses could not be established; in the other case, the initial loan obligation had already been taken into account, and no evidence capable of changing the audit result was submitted. Both appeals were rejected.
Together with each document, show which movement it confirms and how it changes the balance of the disputed month. In these two cases, it was precisely the factual basis of the requested change that remained unconfirmed.
Practical conclusion
The author's recommendation is to show side by side, in a balance table, the opening amount, the inflows, the outflows, the month-end balance and the calculation of the reasonable balance. Link each disputed movement to the document that confirms it. Separately check the responsible person, the method used and the taxation period. In such a table it becomes clearer where your position differs from the audit's calculation.
For further reading on the broader issue of reclassification as the director's salary: eaudit.ge/374-nashti-direktoris-khelpasad.html. The main subject of this article is the calculation and substantiation of the cash balance itself.
Basis: Tax Code, Articles 73.4, 73.9 "ბ", 101.1 and 154.1 "ა", 154.2 "ა"–"ბ"; Annex No. 9 to the methodological guidelines; the reasoning and operative parts of six public decisions.
This is a summary of dispute practice, not legal advice on a specific case.
Sources
- Tax Code of Georgia, No. 3591, 17.09.2010 — Articles 73.4, 73.9 "ბ", 101.1, 154.1 "ა", 154.2 "ა"–"ბ"; publication 247 (15.10.2026): https://matsne.gov.ge/ka/document/view/1043717?publication=247
- Order No. 22708 of the Head of the Revenue Service, 08.07.2019, "On the Approval of Methodological Guidelines for Determining a Person's Tax Liabilities in Certain Cases", Annex No. 9 "On Cash in the Cash Desk", Articles 1, 3–12. The text used is the one provided, with the amendment indicated at the head of the annex — Order No. 15615, 03.07.2023: https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/be517d42-036e-442c-8360-efc76e6f6519
- Revenue Service Order No. 18792, 19.08.2026: https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/6fbb9e88-0595-4eb9-baae-ebc1c2c42e6b
- Revenue Service Order No. 18957, 21.08.2026: https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/5efa0495-da73-4f45-b6b6-a4a9f1a1b1f2
- Revenue Service Order No. 20343, 16.09.2026: https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/3eba1dcf-cafe-4c8f-8638-f0f435174cfd
- Revenue Service Order No. 19274, 27.08.2026: https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/50f79a3e-78f3-4c57-9fe8-9e35b3723ee7
- Revenue Service Order No. 20753, 21.09.2026 (describes the reduction obtained by executing an earlier order; the subsequent appeal was rejected): https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/2a8b5067-cd87-4b0e-969e-c4aa4ab393be
- Revenue Service Order No. 19599, 03.09.2026 (describes the reduction obtained by executing an earlier order; the subsequent appeals were rejected): https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/9a08ea73-ce27-440d-83af-97341ab1f828
Disputes database: 👉 This case and similar disputes — filterable by topic and tax.
Need tax, accounting or legal advice? 👉 Request a consultation — leave your number and we will call you back.