The goods came in. Some were sold, some spoiled and were thrown away, and some went for next to nothing. In the books this was either "written off" as a single amount at the end of the month or not recorded at all.
A tax audit counts differently. From the goods received it subtracts what was sold with documents and the closing stock, as counted in an inventory or calculated from the documents. Whatever is left is treated as sold without documents: a price is applied to it, then VAT and a fine.
At this point one argument appears in the appeal: the goods are perishable and part of them spoiled. In the five decisions reviewed — of the Revenue Service and of the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia — this argument failed to change the assessment in question; the disputes concerned both treating the goods as sold and determining the price. In two other cases the matter was sent back for re-examination, but not because the goods were perishable: the facts could not be fully established. Natural loss is a separate issue: there a norm or an expert opinion opened the question, and the outcome turned on whether the accounting records met the conditions of the norm. Being sent back with instructions is not a win.
What the law says
The Tax Code regulates the write-off procedure directly. Under paragraph 6 of Article 145, when writing off inventory that has expired or is unfit for use or further supply, the taxpayer must notify the tax authority of the write-off — stating the type, quantity and value of the goods — and may write the goods off only once the authority confirms it.
Under paragraph 7, within 10 working days of the taxpayer's request the authority must either confirm the write-off directly or inspect the goods on site and confirm the write-off document. Paragraph 6¹ sets an exception: if the goods were destroyed or lost through force majeure — an earthquake, flood, fire, accident or other emergency or exceptional circumstance — for a reason beyond the taxpayer's control, they may be written off without meeting the conditions of paragraph 6. Spoilage is not named separately in that paragraph.
The second rule concerns shortages. Under paragraph 9 of Article 286, the discovery of a shortage is treated as a supply made at market price at the moment of discovery. If the tax authority found the shortage during an inventory count, the person is additionally fined 10 percent of the market value of the goods. Under paragraph 10 this sanction does not apply in two cases: if the unrecorded shortage does not exceed 2 percent of the recorded goods of the same kind, or if the taxpayer, before the inventory count or audit began, reported the shortage in its tax returns or informed the authority and recognised the shortage as a supply. This is not a write-off: the shortage remains a supply; the paragraph only removes the sanction.
The basis for natural loss norms is paragraph 11 of Article 8: the competent authority may set a maximum permissible amount of loss, and in that case loss above that amount counts as a shortage.
Paragraph 6 of Article 145 was cited expressly in one of the cases reviewed; in the others the absence of an application is recorded as a fact. In most cases the authorities cite paragraph 3 of Article 136 (full recording of all transactions) and subparagraph "ა" of paragraph 5 of Article 73: the authority may use the indirect method if there are no accounting records or the taxable object cannot be determined from them. The text of these articles was the same in the periods under dispute.
What recurs in dispute practice
In five cases (two orders and three Council decisions) the appellant pointed to spoilage or destruction of goods. In all five the appeal was not upheld on this point. Three things recur in the reasoning.
No write-off confirmed by the authority could be seen. In one case the audit recorded that no application to write off expired goods with the Revenue Service's permission was on file. In another, that the taxpayer had not submitted any application about damaged or spoiled goods during the audited period. In the third, the taxpayer had recorded the spoiled goods as sold at a minimal mark-up, while the audit applied a higher mark-up; the Council noted that the file contained no "write-off document for expired and/or unfit inventory" confirmed by the tax authority, and that the appellant "speaks in general terms".
Photos and videos were not accepted as evidence. In one case, according to the audit department's representative, the photo and video material submitted showed neither a vehicle registration number nor the quantity of spoiled goods. In the other case there were only copies of photographs; the Council held that they could not serve as evidence of spoilage.
Whatever was neither written off nor visible in the closing stock was treated as sold. In one case the audit found that the taxpayer's goods were "neither written off nor recorded in the physical count"; according to the audit department, the attached documents did not allow the quantity, type and value of the goods sold to be established. In the other, the stock counted in the inventory differed radically from the stock in the software, and the difference was treated as sold at retail.
In all these cases the reasoning rests on one idea: even at the dispute stage, no evidence was submitted that would change the circumstances established by the audit. The price argument — good-quality goods sold dear, the rest cheap — was not accepted either in three cases where the taxpayer's own documented price was applied.
Two cases sent back — and not because the goods were perishable
In two other cases the appellant likewise relied on the goods being perishable and on low prices; the Council under the Ministry of Finance sent them back for reconsideration because the facts could not be fully established and the Service had not properly examined the disputed issue. One of them shows what a write-off changes: unfit goods written off in the manner prescribed by law were not treated as sold by the audit. The second case went further: on reconsideration the Service refused again, and the Council partly annulled that refusal and instructed the audit department to examine the expert report submitted on the mark-up, with an adjustment only if there were proper grounds. No final reduction appears in either case.
Natural loss — with a norm and without one
The natural loss cases (shrinkage in storage or transport) discussed below did not concern perishable goods. In one case the inventory count found no stock at all; according to the appellant, natural loss was a "commonly known fact", but it named no norm — the 10% fine under paragraph 9 of Article 286 stood.
In three cases the outcome was different. In two, the appellant named a regulation which, according to the text of the decisions, approves loss norms for the goods concerned (two different regulations and goods). In one, the Revenue Service instructed the audit department to determine the loss under those norms and reduce the liability; in the other, it gave the taxpayer a deadline to submit evidence and instructed the audit department to examine it. In the third case, according to the appellant, no norm existed; it submitted an expert report from a private organisation on weight loss in transport, and the Council instructed the audit department to examine it with the taxpayer's participation.
All three are instructions, not an established amount. In one case the next stage is also visible: the recalculation applied the loss only to the stock at the end of the period and reduced the assessment slightly. The Service refused to apply it to the whole quantity, because "the records required for writing off natural loss were not kept in the proper manner". A refusal in a customs offence case that relied on the same regulation, and had earlier been sent back for reconsideration once, was reasoned in the same words. In other words, in both cases under that regulation the outcome turned on whether the taxpayer kept the records the regulation requires. The final outcome of the case under the second regulation is not yet known.
What does not work in an appeal
- A general reference to spoilage that does not show in which part the assessment is wrong (in the Service's refusal orders this is a standard paragraph).
- Photos or videos instead of a write-off document.
- Pointing to spoilage when no write-off notice was sent to the authority and no confirmation exists.
- Citing a natural loss norm without the records that the regulation itself requires for a write-off (two cases, one and the same regulation).
How to frame the request
The wording of the request did not determine the outcome: a request for re-examination — with the appellant's participation and taking the perishability of the goods into account — was rejected in one case. Re-examination was ordered where a regulation or an expert report was submitted, or where the facts could not be fully established.
The author's practical advice: the appeal should show two things: in which part the assessment is wrong, and the document the Code requires — a write-off document confirmed by the authority (paragraphs 6 and 7 of Article 145), and in the case of natural loss, the approved norm and the records that this regulation requires.
Practical conclusion
In all five decisions the spoilage argument without a write-off document failed to change the assessment — in four on the stock, in one on the mark-up. The author's practical advice: before writing off spoiled or unfit goods, notify the authority of their type, quantity and value, and formalise the write-off after it confirms. If a natural loss norm exists for the goods, check which records the regulation requires and keep them. Basis: Articles 145 (paragraphs 6, 6¹ and 7), 286 (paragraphs 9 and 10), 8 (paragraph 11), 136 (paragraph 3) and 73 (subparagraph "ა" of paragraph 5) of the Tax Code of Georgia; decisions of the dispute resolution bodies ("Sources").
📞 Review of your write-off practice and preparation of an appeal: 598 21 27 01
Disclaimer
This is a summary of dispute practice, not legal advice on a specific case. Check the conclusion for your case against the text of the decision.
Sources
- Tax Code of Georgia — Art. 8 (paragraph 11), 73 (subparagraph "ა" of paragraph 5), 136 (paragraph 3), 145 (paragraphs 6, 6¹ and 7), 286 (paragraphs 9 and 10); current version, publication 247 (15.10.2026) — https://matsne.gov.ge/ka/document/view/1043717?publication=247
- Decision of the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia №27958/2/2026 (08.10.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/3383316f-0f04-4572-8039-2e55e9078817
- Revenue Service Order N 20658 (18.09.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/b570132c-4a99-4ad8-a59d-667a2cc393a4
- Revenue Service Order N 18948 (21.08.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/bce3d4a7-fa5d-41ae-b8cb-7578987a7745
- Revenue Service Order N 18127 (11.08.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/335db25a-5318-4a1e-9a55-c7e258a55f5a
- Decision of the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia №27814/2/2026 (07.08.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/d1dec671-6154-4f6c-a056-c4e0a18b6cbf
- Decision of the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia №27821/2/2026 (30.07.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/d1d6f85b-a266-4d5b-8718-652a9d75048e
- Decision of the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia №27127/2/2026 (18.06.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/85b557de-adf4-489a-a013-e1e99c306ea2
- Revenue Service Order N 11626 (27.05.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/a472f011-2942-4bec-b5b5-4af0a1ab7a1d
- Decision of the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia №27078/2/2026 (13.05.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/b30b7597-4b9c-4d73-892f-9b488bca68fd
- Decision of the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia №26720/2/2026 (28.04.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/8b46c0fb-628e-4df8-9bf5-3a7833382a7c
- Revenue Service Order N 6557 (25.03.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/2b68732b-4cc5-4e51-9f3c-f3c2b085011d
- Revenue Service Order N 2152 (03.02.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/2cdc264f-7ba8-4700-b40f-db1a19c34658
- Revenue Service Order N 10 (08.01.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/c51fba02-d35e-44c2-a690-88daa9b62fe1
- Decision of the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia №26296/2/2025 (05.01.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/f0314707-c960-4189-956e-bdb820ce4a09
- Revenue Service Order N 28995 (30.12.2025) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/4549d837-ad9d-4d2b-861b-93417c71caf5
Disputes database: 👉 This case and similar disputes — filter by topic and tax.
Need tax, accounting or legal advice? 👉 Request a consultation — leave your number and we will call you back.