In the two new cases discussed below, the companies provided services under tenders and performed them through natural persons. In both, the tax audit examined, among other data, information from the State Procurement Agency and the taxpayer's documents and established that part of the payment received had not been subjected to VAT. In both, it also found amounts paid to natural persons that had not been taxed at source.
The Revenue Service dismissed both appeals.
What the issue is
In the first case the tax audit examined data from the Revenue Service information system, information on the State Procurement Agency website and documents submitted by the taxpayer. It established that about half of the VAT-taxable turnover for the audited period had been declared. VAT (Articles 159 and 163 of the Tax Code), a fine (Article 275) and penalty interest were assessed on the difference.
In the same case, bank statements revealed payments to natural persons who were not registered as taxpayers. These amounts had not been taxed at source, so income tax and a fine were assessed.
In the second case the tax audit examined State Procurement Agency data and the taxpayer's documents. Amounts credited by the customer had not been taxed in the relevant reporting period — VAT and a fine were assessed. Amounts paid for services to natural persons not registered as entrepreneurs had not been taxed at source — income tax and a fine were assessed.
What arguments were made and what came of them
In the first case the taxpayer pointed out that:
- it had mobilised the funds and was trying to correct its returns in stages;
- the director, on whose approval invoices and returns were prepared, had developed a serious health problem;
- the report contained "formal inaccuracies" — two different figures were given in the VAT part;
- the tender price did not cover unforeseen expenses and the company was operating at a loss;
- after the previous audit it had almost fully corrected the shortcoming concerning payments to natural persons.
As regards the figures in the report, the Revenue Service referred to information from the Audit Department: the difference resulted from deducting creditable VAT. The order contains no separate reasoning on the other arguments. In the authority's assessment, the appellant did not specify in which part the liability had been determined unlawfully. Nor did it submit evidence that would change the circumstances established by the audit.
In the second case the taxpayer said that the differences found by the audit were unknown to it and asked for the matter to be examined further. In the authority's assessment, here too the taxpayer submitted no argument or evidence that would change the established facts.
In the first case the taxpayer was also refused release from the sanction on grounds of good faith (paragraph 7 of Article 269 of the Tax Code). As the authority explained, a bona fide taxpayer is one who acted under an excusable legal error.
What the law requires
The Code sets the VAT filing deadline directly:
"A taxable person registered as a VAT payer shall submit a VAT return to the tax authority no later than the 15th day of the month following the reporting period and shall pay the tax within the same period." (the first paragraph of Article 168 of the Tax Code)
When paying for services to a natural person who is not registered as an individual entrepreneur, an enterprise/organisation or a natural person engaged in business must withhold tax at source. The exceptions, in respect of the relevant activity, are a natural person registered as a VAT payer, a notary, a private enforcement officer, a natural person with micro or small business status and a natural person with fixed taxpayer status (subparagraph "დ" of the first paragraph of Article 154). If the tax was not withheld, the obligation to pay the unwithheld amount to the budget and the sanctions fall on the payer of the income (paragraph 2 of the same Article).
Practical recommendations
Below are our recommendations in light of these two cases:
- Regularly compare your taxed turnover with the payments received under tenders. In both cases the audit examined public procurement data along with other sources.
- Illness of the person responsible. In the first case the appeal was dismissed despite the reference to the director's health problem.
- Before paying a natural person for services, check their status — whether they are registered as an individual entrepreneur and whether, in respect of the relevant activity, they fall into a category excluded by the Code. In both cases income tax was assessed at source on amounts paid to such persons.
- Discrepancy between figures in the report. In the first case the difference between two figures in the report was explained by the deduction of creditable VAT, and the appeal was dismissed on this point as well.
- Support your appeal with arguments and evidence addressing the specific circumstances established by the audit. In both cases the authority noted that no such argument or evidence had been submitted.
Disclaimer
This is a summary of dispute practice, not legal advice on a specific case. Both orders may be appealed to the Council under the Ministry of Finance or to court within 20 calendar days of service; these sources contain no information on any further appeal or its outcome.
Sources
- Tax Code of Georgia No 3591 (17.09.2010) — Articles 154 (subparagraph "დ" of the first paragraph, paragraph 2), 159 (subparagraphs "ა" and "ბ" of the first paragraph), 163 (the first paragraph and paragraph 2), 168 (the first paragraph), 269 (paragraph 7), 275 — current edition (publication 246, from 30.09.2026): https://matsne.gov.ge/ka/document/view/1043717?publication=246
- Revenue Service Order N 22776 (12.10.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/83495e46-3e26-423f-9c7d-e5d12c9867f3
- Revenue Service Order N 21676 (02.10.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/9ee36404-888c-4630-aa81-278ee6d823ec
Need tax, accounting or legal advice? 👉 Request a consultation — leave us your number and we will call you back.