Writing off materials is a routine operation for an accountant: the materials were used in construction, repairs or fit-out works, or they spoiled. A taxpayer must keep full records of all operations so that their start, progress and completion can be controlled (Tax Code, Article 136, paragraph 3). In the two cases discussed below, the accounting write-off was not enough to prove that the disputed quantity had been used, or to prove the grounds for the write-off.
In one case this was established on the basis of an expert opinion, in the other because there was no write-off document. In both the result was twofold: the materials were treated as sold and charged with VAT (Tax Code, Article 159, paragraph one, subparagraph "ა"; Article 163), and their value was treated as salary paid to the director and charged with income tax withheld at source (Article 101, paragraph one; Article 154, paragraph one, subparagraph "ა"). In both cases a fine was also imposed (Article 275).
What the issue is
In the new case, a company had written off materials for the fit-out of leased premises. On the basis of an opinion of the National Forensics Bureau and communication with the expert, the tax audit established that the volume actually used was less than half of what had been written off, even on the highest estimate. The difference was treated as sold, and its value as the director's salary.
In its appeal, the taxpayer stated that the expert examination had not taken into account additional work required because of the soil. According to the taxpayer, if that work were included the difference would be small, and for works of that scale it was "logical and acceptable". The same appeal also disputed a discrepancy in the cash balance: the taxpayer attributed it to carelessness and offered to submit documents and corrected accounting software records.
What the authority decided and why
The Revenue Service did not uphold the appeal on any issue. On five assessment issues the reason was the same: in the authority's view, no argument or evidence capable of changing the facts established by the tax audit had been submitted during the review of the dispute.
In requalifying the amount as salary, the authority relied on Article 73 of the Tax Code: if the form of a transaction does not correspond to its substance, the tax authority has the right to change its classification (paragraph 9, subparagraph "ბ"), and
"if any amount is used in the interests of a particular person, that amount shall be deemed to have been received by that person." (Tax Code, Article 73, paragraph 4)
In this case the hearing was postponed at the taxpayer's request, but on the new date its representative did not appear and did not ask for another postponement. Under the Code, in such a situation the appeal may be considered in the absence of the appellant (Tax Code, Article 302, paragraphs 6 and 8).
There was also a separate request for release from sanctions on grounds of good faith (Tax Code, Article 269, paragraph 7) — it concerned the fines relating to VAT credit and unrecorded goods, and it was not granted either. As the authority explained, a taxpayer acting in good faith is one who acted under an excusable legal error, whereas in this case the obligation had in fact been fulfilled only in part.
What the second case shows
In the case considered by the Council under the Ministry of Finance, the company had no document recording the write-off of part of its goods. The tax audit applied to those goods the mark-up recorded in the company's accounting software, treated the goods as sold, and treated the market value of the sale as the director's salary. At the Council hearing the taxpayer stated that the goods written off were unusable, but it could not submit evidence of this, and the Council did not accept the argument.
The Council also listed the kind of evidence that was missing: an expert opinion, a certificate issued by the competent authority, or a write-off document confirmed by the tax authority. In the same case, the tax audit took into account the part of the goods whose theft was confirmed by a police certificate.
In this case too the taxpayer sought release from the fine under Article 269, paragraph 7, and was refused.
What was missing and what the law requires
In both cases the quantity written off, or the grounds for the write-off, could not be proved by documents, and in the dispute the authority did not consider the arguments and materials submitted sufficient to change the circumstances established by the tax audit.
The Code sets out the procedure for writing off unusable or expired goods directly:
"When writing off inventory items that are expired and/or unfit for use or further supply, the taxpayer shall notify the tax authority of the write-off of the inventory items (stating the type, quantity and value of the inventory items) and shall carry out the write-off only upon the relevant confirmation by the tax authority." (Tax Code, Article 145, paragraph 6)
This condition does not apply to goods destroyed or lost for reasons beyond the taxpayer's control as a result of force majeure (earthquake, flood, fire, accident, etc.) (Article 145, paragraph 6¹).
Practical recommendations
Below are our recommendations in light of these two cases:
- Prove the quantity written off with documents, not just an accounting entry. If you use materials for your own construction, repairs or fit-out works, keep the documents that show the volume used.
- Unusable or expired goods — only after notifying the tax authority and receiving its confirmation (Article 145, paragraph 6).
- Theft. In the second case, the tax audit took into account the theft confirmed by a police certificate.
- In a dispute — specific evidence and calculations. In the first case, the authority did not consider an explanation contradicting the expert opinion sufficient to change the established circumstances, and in the second, the statement that the goods were unusable was not backed by supporting evidence.
- Attend the hearing with your evidence. If you cannot, ask for a postponement in good time. In the second case, the Council did not consider the explanations given at the oral hearing sufficient to change the assessment.
Disclaimer
This is a summary of dispute practice, not legal advice on a specific case. In the new case, the order could be appealed to the Council under the Ministry of Finance or to court within 20 calendar days of service, so it should not be regarded as the final outcome of the case.
Sources
- Tax Code of Georgia №3591 (17.09.2010) — Art. 73 (paragraph 4, paragraph 9, subparagraph "ბ"), 101 (paragraph one), 136 (paragraph 3), 145 (paragraphs one, 6 and 6¹), 154 (paragraph one, subparagraph "ა"), 159 (paragraph one, subparagraph "ა"), 163 (paragraphs one and 2), 269 (paragraph 7), 275, 302 (paragraphs 6 and 8) — current version (publication 246, from 30.09.2026), checked on 13.10.2026: https://matsne.gov.ge/ka/document/view/1043717?publication=246
- Revenue Service order N 19033 (24.08.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/7dc4ccef-2650-43a9-990b-47a8465f506e
- Decision of the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia №26731/2/2026 (17.03.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/e93d9e4a-7782-4190-9caa-1f1629c302e4
Need tax, accounting or legal advice? 👉 Request a consultation — leave your number and we will call you back.