At the end of September the Revenue Service dismissed two customs appeals. In the first, an importer argued that a sealed cargo had ended up in its warehouse through the carrier's error. In the second, an airport passenger said he had chosen the "green channel" out of ignorance. In both cases the fine stood. In early October a third case was decided along the same lines — on gold coins brought in through the "green channel".
All three cases share the same logic. A customs sanction is imposed for a formal breach, and releasing a person from the sanction for a breach committed by mistake or out of ignorance is the authority's right, not its obligation. Below we look at what the law says, why the arguments failed and what you can do in good time.
1. A customs seal in your own warehouse
What happened
The importer's container was dispatched under a customs seal and with a registration certificate to a customs clearance economic zone. Instead of the zone, the vehicle turned up at the company's warehouse, where the seal was removed without customs consent and the goods were unloaded. The company itself informed customs a few days later, but at the inspection the goods could no longer be identified.
The result: a fine equal to 100% of the import charges. Alongside it, the import charges themselves (VAT and import tax) were assessed in the same amount under a separate tax notice, together with penalty interest. One mistake effectively doubled the customs cost of the cargo.
What the law says
Under paragraph 2 of Article 70 of the Customs Code, goods remain under customs supervision until their customs status is determined, and they may not be removed or disposed of without the consent of the customs authority. Under Article 172, an act that results in the unlawful disposal, loss or destruction of goods under customs supervision is punishable by a fine of 100 percent of the import charges payable on identical/similar goods.
Why it failed
The company relied on two arguments: transport and customs procedures were the carrier's responsibility, and the company itself contacted customs as soon as it learned of the breach. Paragraph 11 of Article 163 gives the customs authority, the dispute resolution body or the court the right to release a person from a sanction if the breach was committed by mistake or out of ignorance. The authority linked this rule to a mistake of law — where the person did not know, and could not have known, that the act was prohibited. A contractor's negligence was not treated as such a mistake. The authority did not separately address the self-reporting — what was decisive was that the goods could no longer be identified.
For comparison: in one June case the Revenue Service lifted a fine under the same Article 172 conditionally, under paragraph 11 of Article 163 — provided the person paid the import charges within 10 days. There the appellant asked precisely for the fine to be lifted and did not contest the tax. The rule is discretionary, and the outcome depends on the facts of the particular case.
What to check
- A sealed cargo is not opened before clearance. If a cargo arrives at your warehouse sealed, contact customs first.
- Agree the place of arrival with the carrier or forwarder in writing, and explain to warehouse staff that a seal means the goods are still under customs supervision.
- If a mistake does happen, show in the appeal with facts, rather than a general "mistake", why it was excusable, and state clearly what you are asking for: the fine to be lifted or the decision to be annulled in full.
2. The "green channel" with cash
What happened
A foreign national who arrived at the airport left the customs control area through the "green channel". He was stopped on his way to the exit, and foreign currency was found in his handbag — more than GEL 50,000 at the National Bank exchange rate. The passenger paid the fine the same day and then appealed it: "I followed the crowd, I didn't know."
What the law says
Under subparagraph "ჟ" of Article 6 of the Customs Code, goods are any tangible property moved across the customs border, including money. Under the instruction approved by Order No. 257 of the Minister of Finance of 29 August 2019 (Annex No. 8, Art. 2, item 15 "დ"), cash, cheques and other securities moved across the border are subject to declaration if their total exceeds GEL 30,000 or its equivalent. Under the same instruction (Art. 6, item 2 "ს"), a document confirming the origin and purpose of such an amount must be submitted.
Under paragraph 2 of Article 169 of the Customs Code, taking out or bringing in cash of more than GEL 50,000 but not more than GEL 100,000 by bypassing customs control, concealing it from customs control or declaring it incorrectly is punishable by a fine of GEL 5,000 or confiscation of the amount without compensation.
Why it failed
The Revenue Service pointed out that the passenger's obligations are written at the channels in Georgian, English and Russian: the red channel asks anyone carrying goods subject to declaration to approach customs, and the green one reads "not subject to declaration". The passenger did not approach customs to declare. For the authority, choosing the green channel was in itself a statement that no goods subject to declaration were being moved.
Of the two alternatives in Article 169, the passenger received the lighter sanction — a GEL 5,000 fine — rather than confiscation of the whole amount. Paying the fine on the same day did not prevent the appeal from being considered on its merits.
What to check
- If your cash, cheques and securities together exceed GEL 30,000 (in any currency), choose the red channel and declare the amount.
- Carry a document confirming the origin and purpose of the money.
- If the amount exceeds GEL 50,000 (up to GEL 100,000), the price of a mistake is a GEL 5,000 fine or confiscation of the whole amount.
3. The "green channel" and gold coins
What happened
A citizen arriving on a flight was leaving the customs control area through the "green channel". A customs officer stopped him and asked whether he was carrying any goods subject to declaration, including jewellery, gold or silver. The passenger said no — this was recorded by a body-worn camera. When his hand luggage was inspected, two gold coins were found in his wallet. He said the coins were a family keepsake that he had carried with him for years, and that he did not know about the obligation to declare them.
What the law says
Under the instruction approved by Order No. 257 (Annex No. 8, Art. 2, item 15 "ბ"), an individual must declare goods if the quantity or value of the goods brought in exceeds the tax-free allowance set by Article 199 of the Tax Code. Under the first paragraph of Article 168 of the Customs Code, bringing in goods (other than cash and securities) by bypassing customs control or concealing them from it is punishable by a fine of 100 percent of the customs value of the goods or confiscation of the goods without compensation.
Why it failed
The authority upheld a fine equal to the customs value of the goods. What was decisive was the choice of the green channel and the negative answer to the oral question. The authority again assessed the ignorance argument under paragraph 11 of Article 163 and applied it only to an excusable mistake of law — where the person did not know and could not have known. Pointing to a first offence and to the personal nature of the item did not change the outcome.
What to check
- Declare gold and jewellery in the red channel, even personal items, if they exceed the tax-free threshold.
- Your answer to a customs officer's oral question may be recorded on camera and become evidence — that is what happened in this case.
Practical conclusion
In all three cases the authority assessed a formal fact: the seal was removed without consent, and cash and gold were brought in without being declared. Release from a sanction for a mistake or ignorance exists in the law, but it is the authority's right and must be specifically justified — a general "the carrier made a mistake" or "I didn't know" is not enough. The cheapest route is prevention: a sealed cargo stays untouched until clearance, and a traveller with a large sum of money or jewellery chooses the red channel.
This is a summary of dispute practice, not legal advice on a specific case. A detailed analysis of all three decisions is available in our disputes database: https://ai.eaudit.ge/davebi/
Basis: Customs Code of Georgia — Art. 6 ("ჟ"), 70 (para. 2), 163 (para. 11), 168 (para. 1), 169 (para. 2), 172, current version, checked on 12.10.2026 (matsne.gov.ge); Order No. 257 of the Minister of Finance of 29.08.2019, Annex No. 8 — Art. 2 (item 15 "ბ", "დ"), Art. 6 (item 2 "ს"), current version, checked on 12.10.2026 (matsne.gov.ge); Revenue Service orders: N 21451, 30.09.2026 (infohub.rs.ge); N 21197, 29.09.2026 (infohub.rs.ge); N 22044, 06.10.2026 (infohub.rs.ge); N 14635, 30.06.2026 (infohub.rs.ge).
We cover the conduct of tax and customs disputes in depth in our course "Tax and Financial Analysis of a Company in Excel": https://eaudit.ge/index.php?newsid=347
📞 Review of a customs fine dispute: 598 21 27 01
Need tax, accounting or legal advice? 👉 Request a consultation — leave your number and we will call you back.