When the Revenue Service or the Council under the Ministry of Finance sends a case back for further examination, it may look as if the dispute has been won. In reality this is only an opportunity so far — the outcome depends on what the authority instructs and what the examination shows.
In the case described below, the assessment was reduced by more than half in two stages — first by taking full account of the primary documents issued for the goods sold, and then through debtors confirming their balances. The final outcome is not yet known.
What the issue is
The company kept no records, so the tax audit determined its tax liability by the indirect method (Tax Code, Article 73, paragraph 5, subparagraph "ა"): income was estimated using a mark-up, and the disposable amount derived from the cash flow was treated as the director's salary. VAT, income tax and sanctions were assessed.
The dispute ran along two lines:
- The mark-up. The Revenue Service instructed the audit to take full account of the primary documents issued for the goods sold when refining the mark-up. After recalculation, the average mark-up matched the declared one — the VAT and the related fine were cancelled in full, and the income tax was also reduced.
- The debtors. The Council under the Ministry of Finance sent the issue of accounts receivable back for reconsideration, and the Revenue Service instructed the audit to examine it with the taxpayer's participation. Under Article 70 of the Tax Code, the audit requested information from the debtors as at the beginning and the end of the period. Only the debtors who confirmed the taxpayer's data were reflected in the cash flow — and the assessment was reduced further.
In its latest order, the Revenue Service gave the taxpayer 15 calendar days from service of the order to submit notarised explanations from those debtors about whose debts the Service had no information. In the remaining part the appeal was dismissed.
What brought about the reduction
- Primary documents for calculating the mark-up. Once the audit took into account all identifiable documents issued for the goods sold, the indirect estimate came close to the declared figure.
- Third-party confirmation of receivable balances. Only the receivable balances that the debtor itself confirmed were reflected in the cash flow.
What opportunity the taxpayer received
For the debtors about whom the Service had no information, the Revenue Service itself set the form of proof and the time limit: a notarised explanation within 15 calendar days of service of the order. If this evidence is submitted, the audit is required to examine it and, taking the result into account, to reduce the assessment. The outcome of this stage does not yet appear in the published decisions.
What was missing and what was not upheld
- Reconciliation statements only for the end of the period. The balances were recorded in the accounting software, but reconciliation statements with debtors were submitted only for the end-of-period figures — they did not confirm the opening balance, so the audit requested additional information from the debtors.
- Debtors who denied the debt. The authority gave no further instruction regarding them — this part remained "in the remaining part".
- General objections. "Not all circumstances were examined" and "the disposable amount is not stated in the report" — these arguments produced no separate result: at the last stage, the partial satisfaction related to the specific issue of the debtors, and when the implementation was appealed, the authority checked whether the recalculation complied with the previous instruction.
- Appealing the method a second time. At one stage the appeal was left without consideration as regards the indirect method, because a decision of the same authority on the same subject already existed:
"The dispute resolution body shall not consider an appeal if: … ზ) there is a decision taken by the same body in respect of the same appellant on the same subject of dispute;" (Tax Code, Article 301)
What other cases show as well
The same picture can be seen elsewhere in dispute practice: at the implementation stage, the authority checks whether the adjusted notice complies with the previous instruction and whether evidence capable of changing the established facts has been submitted. In other cases a reduction came, for example, from a bank statement for the full period and a reconciliation statement from the supplier, while renewed criticism of the method produced no result. This is not a universal rule — each case had its own specific reason.
Practical conclusion
- Do not treat a referral back as a win. The outcome depends on what the authority instructs and what the examination shows — in this case the reduction came where the examination relied on documents and on confirmation by third parties.
- Reconciliation statements — for both the opening and the closing balance. In this case the audit specifically noted that the statements covered only the end of the period.
- Start working with your debtors in good time. In this case, for the debtors about whom it had no information, the authority required a notarised explanation, with a time limit of 15 calendar days from service of the order.
- At the implementation stage, state specifically in which part the instruction was not carried out and which document proves this — in this case general objections produced no separate result.
Disclaimer
This material is of a general nature and is based on public dispute decisions and the current version of the Tax Code. The final outcome of the case described is not yet known. The material is not a substitute for advice on a specific case — every dispute is assessed individually.
Sources
- Tax Code of Georgia — Art. 70, Article 73, paragraph 5, subparagraph "ა", Article 301, subparagraph "ზ" (current version, matsne.gov.ge)
- Published decisions of the Revenue Service and of the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia (infohub.rs.ge)
For a consultation: 598 21 27 01 (phone/WhatsApp/Viber) · mail@eaudit.ge
Need tax, accounting or legal advice? 👉 Request a consultation — leave your number and we will call you back.