An individual found a factory defect — a battery and screen problem — in a smartphone bought online abroad. The manufacturer confirmed a warranty replacement and assigned a return number. On its instructions, the defective device was sent back first. Once it had received it, the manufacturer shipped a replacement — a newer model, because the old one was no longer in stock. In the manufacturer's emails the total was zero.
The parcel arrived in Georgia. According to the recipient, the system would not accept zero in the value declaration, so a token amount was entered — about 96 units of a foreign currency. During customs formalities it emerged that the declared value was incorrect. No invoice was submitted, so an expert examination was ordered, which valued the phone at almost 16 times the declared amount.
The result: a customs offence report and a fine of more than GEL 700 — exactly 100% of the understated import charges. On top of that came the charges themselves and the fee for the expert examination. The Revenue Service dismissed the appeal. The Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia also refused it (October 2026).
Why the "free replacement" could not be proved
The appellant argued that this was not a new purchase but a warranty exchange: one device went out, another came in, and the transaction value was zero. The Council did not accept this, and one circumstance proved decisive: no re-export of the defective phone had been formalised.
Paragraph 3 of Article 160 of the Customs Code provides for exactly this situation. If goods released for free circulation are defective and are returned to the supplier, they may be placed under re-export. Because this route was not used, customs could not establish that the parcel contained a free replacement for an item already bought and cleared. Correspondence with the manufacturer cannot replace this procedure.
The declaration rules are just as clear. The declarant must report information correctly and in full, and any attached document must be genuine and accurate (paragraph 2 of Article 13 of the Customs Code). The value declaration for a parcel bought online is completed on the basis of the sales document, i.e. the invoice (Order No. 257, Annex No. 8, Art. 31.2). The declarant must keep the invoice and present it to customs on request (Art. 31.3). An amount entered "for the system" and not backed by a document turned out to be incorrect data.
Why 100% and not 40%
Many people have heard that customs fines are reduced for individuals. That is true, but it does not apply to parcels:
- Customs Code 167.1: understating import charges through incorrect data in a declaration — a fine of 100% of the understated amount; for a repeat offence, 200% (167.2).
- 167.3: for an individual's goods worth up to GEL 3,000 the fine is 40% — except for goods brought in by postal item.
A phone that arrives by parcel is subject to the 100% fine, whatever its value.
The Code also offers one safeguard (167.5): only data whose inaccuracy is confirmed by evidence counts as an offence. A doubt that may justify an adjustment of the customs value is not in itself an offence. In this case the evidence was the expert examination.
The Council also recalled that imports by an individual, by postal item, of goods worth up to GEL 300 and weighing up to 30 kg that are not intended for economic activity (groups 28–97 of the commodity nomenclature) are exempt from import tax (subparagraph "დ.ვ" of Article 199 of the Tax Code). The value established by the expert examination exceeded that threshold many times over — the difference in charges alone was more than GEL 700.
What to do — step by step
1. Before sending the defective item — re-export. Annex No. 16 to Order No. 257 ("On Re-export", Art. 1.3) sets four conditions for the re-export of defective goods:
- the goods must not have been used or processed in Georgia;
- customs must be able to identify them;
- the re-export declaration must be accompanied by your statement about the defect and the supplier's written consent to the return. If you bought the item directly from the manufacturer, its warranty letter may serve this purpose;
- the goods must leave within 6 months of release for free circulation.
For goods sent out by parcel, the re-export declaration is completed by the customs authority or by the postal carrier representing the sender (Annex No. 8, Art. 5.5). So when you send the item, tell the carrier directly that this is a re-export and hand over the documents.
Re-export gives you more than protection from a fine: the import charges paid when the defective goods were cleared can be refunded or offset against future liabilities (Customs Code 160.4."ა").
⚠️ If you used the phone for months, or 6 months have already passed, this route may no longer be available. The replacement is then valued as a new import — which is what the second step covers.
2. When receiving the replacement — not a token amount, but a value determined by customs. If you have no invoice and the value cannot be established, at the recipient's request the customs authority may carry out an expert examination or determine the customs value of the goods (Annex No. 8, Art. 31.6). You will still pay the charges, but there will be no incorrect data in the declaration — the ground for a fine under 167.1. Entering a token amount is exactly what creates that ground.
3. Keep the documents in one place. The invoice, the warranty letter, the return number, the re-export declaration and the parcel tracking numbers — customs may ask for any of them.
Practical conclusion
A warranty replacement is free for the manufacturer, but for customs it is free only when the old item's departure has been formalised as a re-export. Otherwise the replacement is a new import, and for a parcel an error in the declaration is fined at 100% of the understated charges.
An analysis of this and other disputes: ai.eaudit.ge/davebi.
📞 For a consultation, contact us: +995 598 212 701 · mail@eaudit.ge
Sources
- Customs Code of Georgia — Art. 13.2, 160.3–160.4, 167.1–167.3, 167.5 (matsne.gov.ge, doc. 4598501; version of 05.04.2023, Law No. 2767).
- Order No. 257 of the Minister of Finance of Georgia of 29 August 2019 "On Approval of Instructions on the Movement and Clearance of Goods in the Customs Territory of Georgia" — Annex No. 8, Art. 5.5, 31.2, 31.3, 31.6; Annex No. 16, Art. 1.3 (infohub.rs.ge, current consolidated text).
- Tax Code of Georgia — Art. 199, subparagraph "დ.ვ" (matsne.gov.ge, doc. 1043717; version of 17.12.2025).
- Decision of the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia №27865/2/2026, 05.10.2026 (infohub.rs.ge).
Need tax, accounting or legal advice? 👉 Request a consultation — leave your number and we will call you back.