Elit Audit
ქართულიРусский

An appeal against enforcement — why it does not restart the dispute and what works in the "second round"

This is a translation of an article published in Georgian on 12.10.2026. It describes the rules as they stood on that date. Where the translation and the Georgian original differ, the Georgian text prevails; provisions of Georgian law are binding only in Georgian. Subparagraph letters are given as in the Georgian text of the law.

The most common "partial win" in a tax dispute looks like this: the dispute resolution council writes in its order that the taxpayer is given a period to submit evidence, and the audit department is instructed to examine it and, if there are grounds, to adjust the liability. The audit unit writes a recalculation report, the taxpayer receives an adjusted tax notice — and if he does not like the result, he turns to the council again.

It is precisely on this "second round" appeal that the practice of the past year has been very consistent. The four decisions we discuss below answer one and the same question: what does the authority examine when what is appealed is not the original assessment but the enforcement of a previous decision?

The provision that decides everything

Under paragraph 2¹ of Article 304 of the Tax Code, if the decision or tax notice under appeal was issued in accordance with a decision made by a dispute resolution body, the dispute resolution body makes a decision refusing to uphold the appeal. The matter is considered by the body in accordance with whose decision the act under appeal was issued.

This provision concerns the Revenue Service's council; the Council under the Ministry of Finance, which reviews such refusals by the Revenue Service, issues its own refusal under subparagraph "გ" of the first paragraph of Article 304, but examines the same thing. In practice it looks like this: in an appeal against enforcement, the authority compares the operative part of the previous order with the audit unit's recalculation report and checks whether the second corresponds to the first and whether the appellant has submitted new evidence that changes the facts. In the cases discussed below, raising the substantive issue again led nowhere.

Case one: what worked, worked at the enforcement stage

For a trading company, the audit determined its liabilities by the indirect method and classified as the director's salary a "fictitious" balance derived from a cash flow analysis. The case went through two instances and three orders; the last order gave the taxpayer 15 days to submit documentary evidence and instructed the audit unit to examine it.

At the enforcement stage, the taxpayer submitted what it had not had during the audit: a bank statement for the full period and a reconciliation statement signed with a local supplier, together with an explanation. The audit report states directly that this information "affects the cash balance calculated by the audit, which is reduced by the amounts of principal/interest paid on the loan", and that the accounts payable paid to the supplier are to be deducted. The balance treated as salary was adjusted and the assessment was reduced.

The taxpayer then appealed the adjusted notice as well — on two arguments: that the information had not been properly examined, and that the indirect method had been unfounded from the outset. The council rejected both. The order states that the taxpayer "fails to indicate in the appeal the factual and legal circumstances as to which part of the Revenue Service's decision was not enforced", and that the act under appeal corresponds to the previous decision.

The lesson is clear: the reduction came not from the appeal but from the specific document submitted at the enforcement stage. The second appeal, which repeated the criticism of the method, added nothing.

Case two: "has not submitted at any stage"

The case of a company trading in petroleum products reached the Council under the Ministry of Finance. The taxpayer argued that the investigation information had not been properly taken into account in the recalculation and that the price of the vehicles had also been determined incorrectly. The Council found the recalculation to be in line with the previous order and noted that the taxpayer "has not submitted at any stage of the tax dispute documentation/evidence that would change the factual circumstances reflected in the report issued on the recalculation of the tax audit results".

A second line is visible here as well: the Council noted separately that the appellant was referring to circumstances that had already been rejected by the first order and whose examination had not been assigned to the audit unit. In this case no reduction was made at all at the enforcement stage, and the Council considered this, too, to be in line with the previous order — the issues you lost at the previous stage were not reopened here.

Case three: "more" after a partial reduction

For a construction company, enforcement of the previous order had already reduced the assessment substantially — among other things because the previous order directly required a reduction of liabilities in the part relating to the sale of heavy machinery. In a new appeal, the company sought a further adjustment on the basis of detailed data on materials used on projects. The Revenue Service found that the enforcement "was carried out on the basis of an investigation/examination of all circumstances of material significance to the case", that the act under appeal corresponded to the previous decision, and the appeal was not upheld. General project tables could not replace evidence traceable to specific materials. This order was appealed to the Council under the Ministry of Finance; the outcome of that stage is not discussed in this article.

An exception that proves the rule

In one case, the Council under the Ministry of Finance set aside an order of the Revenue Service and returned the case for reconsideration. The reason was not substantive: the Council found that "the arguments put forward by the appellant were not properly examined/investigated by the Revenue Service" — the taxpayer had pointed to specific calculation errors, while the Revenue Service justified its refusal in a single sentence. This, too, is an appeal against enforcement, but the difference is stark: the argument was specific and the authority did not investigate it.

Two caveats are essential here as well. First, this is a remand, not a win: the amount was not written off, and the case is being reconsidered. Second, the Council did not say that the argument was correct; it said only that the argument had not been examined.

What this means in practice

  1. Documents belong at the enforcement stage. A full bank statement, a reconciliation statement, a loan agreement that was actually performed work precisely in the window opened by the previous order. After that window, a new document will not "fit" into a new appeal.
  2. An appeal against enforcement must be specific. State which instruction was not carried out, in what part and by what figure. "The information was not examined" does not work without specifics; a specific argument that was not investigated, on the other hand, may become a ground for setting the order aside.
  3. Dispute the method in the first round. The lawfulness of the indirect method, the classification of a balance as salary, the grounds for applying Article 73 — all of this must be settled in the first appeal. In the cases discussed, the authority did not deal with these arguments again, relying on paragraph 2¹ of Article 304.
  4. The time limit is the same. An unfavourable decision of the Revenue Service is appealed to the Council under the Ministry of Finance within 20 days of delivery (the first paragraph of Article 305) — an enforcement order as well.

Conclusion

"Partially upheld" often means only that a window for evidence has been opened. The real reduction happens in that window — with a specific document, together with the audit unit. Once the window has closed, a new appeal with old arguments ended in refusal in the cases discussed; the exception arose where the authority did not investigate a specific argument at all.


This article is a summary of public practice and is not advice on a specific case. Verify the conclusions against the text of the decisions themselves and the current version of the law.

Source: Tax Code of Georgia — the 6th paragraph of Article 302, paragraph 2¹ of Article 304, the first paragraph of Article 305 (matsne.gov.ge, current version); orders of the Revenue Service's Dispute Resolution Council N 20626 (18.09.2026) and N 27419 (12.12.2025); decisions of the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia №27830/2/2026 (24.08.2026) and №27404/2/2026 (30.06.2026) — infohub.rs.ge. Cards for all four cases: ai.eaudit.ge/davebi (DS-IND-13013, DS-IND-14007, DS-IND-14020, DS-SXV-0520).

Need tax, accounting or legal advice? 👉 Request a consultation — leave your number and we will call you back.

← All articles

Elit Audit

Talk to us

Tell us which service you need — we will discuss the details together.

+995 598 21 27 01mail@eaudit.ge
Lublianis St. 13b, Digomi, Tbilisi, Georgia
Contact form (in Georgian)