Elit Audit
ქართულიРусский

The Council sent the case back, and you went to court? — the trap of subparagraph "ი" of Article 301

This is a translation of an article published in Georgian on 12.10.2026. It describes the rules as they stood on that date. Where the translation and the Georgian original differ, the Georgian text prevails; provisions of Georgian law are binding only in Georgian. Subparagraph letters are given as in the Georgian text of the law.

One of the most welcome outcomes in a tax dispute is when the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia annuls the decision of the Revenue Service and sends the case back for reconsideration. It is not yet a final win, but it is a real chance to have the assessment reviewed while still at the administrative stage.

That chance can be lost in a single step: if you go to court on the same issue before the reconsideration is over, the Revenue Service will no longer consider the appeal.

What the issue is

In a recently published case, a company was assessed VAT, a fine and penalty interest following a tax audit. The Revenue Service did not uphold the appeal. The Council under the Ministry of Finance, however, taking into account the appellant's arguments and evidence, found that the disputed issue needed further examination. The Service's decision was partly annulled and the appeal was sent back for reconsideration with the appellant's participation.

While the Revenue Service was reconsidering the appeal, the company went to court and asked for the same tax notice to be declared void. The court accepted the claim for proceedings. The Revenue Service did not consider the appeal on the merits and left it without consideration.

As a result, the administrative reconsideration ordered by the Council never took place on the merits. The order leaving the appeal without consideration can itself be appealed.

What the law says

Article 301 of the Tax Code of Georgia lists the cases in which the body hearing the dispute does not consider an appeal. One of them is subparagraph "ი":

"The body hearing the dispute shall not consider an appeal if: … ი) the appellant has applied to a court on the same subject matter of the dispute;"

The purpose of the rule is clear: an administrative body and a court do not deal with the same issue at the same time. The decisive words are "on the same subject matter of the dispute".

What practice shows

Subparagraph "ი" of Article 301 is applied repeatedly in published dispute decisions. Three of them show well where the line runs:

  • A claim against the same tax notice. In the case described above, both the claim and the appeal concerned one and the same tax notice. The Revenue Service treated this as the same subject matter of the dispute and left the appeal that had been sent back without consideration.
  • The part sent back was not challenged in court. In another case the Council sent part of the appeal back for reconsideration. The Revenue Service left this too without consideration under subparagraph "ი" of Article 301, but the Council found this unlawful. The Council relied on the claimant's statement that it had not challenged the decision in court as regards the part sent back for reconsideration. The Service therefore should have dealt with the part sent back.
  • Court first, Council second. In the third case an entrepreneur appealed enforcement measures — an attachment of property and a debit of funds from a bank account — to the Revenue Service and was refused. He then asked the court to declare the same acts void and, after the court's judgment, also appealed the same order to the Council under the Ministry of Finance. The Council did not consider the appeal on the merits: a court had already been applied to on the same subject matter of the dispute, so the appeal was left without consideration under subparagraph "ი" of Article 301.

All three decisions point the same way: what matters is what exactly has been challenged in court. The mere fact of going to court does not determine this.

Practical conclusion

  1. The Council sent the case back? Make a conscious decision. Either you wait for the outcome of the administrative reconsideration, or you go to court knowing that the reconsideration of the same issue will stop.
  2. Define the scope of the claim precisely. If you disagree with part of the Council's decision and challenge it in court, the claim should make it clear that you are not challenging the part sent back for reconsideration. A claim to have the whole tax notice declared void may be treated as the same subject matter of the dispute.
  3. Watch the deadlines. The part of the Council's decision in which the appeal was not upheld is challenged in court within the time limit stated in the decision. So the dilemma may arise precisely while the reconsideration is still under way.

Risks

  • If the claim covers the whole tax notice, the administrative reconsideration ordered on remand may be discontinued, and the chance to have the assessment reviewed may be lost.
  • Whether it is "the same subject matter of the dispute" depends on the specific claim and the specific appeal. The two cases described above do not create a general rule — they show what the authority pays attention to.

Disclaimer

This material is general in nature and is based on public dispute decisions and the wording of the Tax Code currently in force. It does not replace advice on a specific case — every dispute is assessed individually.

Sources

  • Tax Code of Georgia — Article 301, subparagraph "ი" (wording in force, matsne.gov.ge)
  • Published decisions of the Revenue Service and of the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia (infohub.rs.ge)
  • Decision of the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia №27886/2/2026, 07.10.2026 — infohub.rs.ge; previous stage: Revenue Service Order N 3986, 23.02.2026 — infohub.rs.ge (added 13.10.2026)

For a consultation: 598 21 27 01 (phone/WhatsApp/Viber) · mail@eaudit.ge

Need tax, accounting or legal advice? 👉 Request a consultation — leave your number and we will call you back.

← All articles

Elit Audit

Talk to us

Tell us which service you need — we will discuss the details together.

+995 598 21 27 01mail@eaudit.ge
Lublianis St. 13b, Digomi, Tbilisi, Georgia
Contact form (in Georgian)