In October the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia dismissed two appeals. Both concern Article 286 of the Tax Code: "Transportation, sale and non-recording of goods without documents". In the first case the company argued that moving its own raw material internally does not require a waybill. In the second, it argued that the stocktake fine had been calculated with an inflated mark-up.
Both arguments are often heard in practice. Below we look at what the Code says, why these arguments failed and what you can check in your own company today.
1. A waybill for your own goods
What happened
A company was hauling its own raw material along an internal road from the extraction site to its own processing workshop. The goods were not supplied to anyone and their owner did not change. The vehicle was stopped, no waybill was found in the tax authority's system, and the company was fined GEL 500 under the first paragraph of Article 286.
The company's position was that this is an internal stage of a single production process, there was no supply, and the adjacent plots are not "territorially separate units" of the enterprise.
Why it failed
Paragraph 4 of Article 136 of the Tax Code requires a waybill "when goods are transported within the country for business activity". The rule does not make supply a condition; on a supply, a waybill is additionally issued at the buyer's request as well. The first paragraph of Article 286 fines transportation without a waybill GEL 500. If the same violation is repeated within 12 months of the previous violation being detected (paragraph 8 of Article 269), the fine is GEL 5 000 (paragraph 2 of Article 286).
The route proved decisive. The Council accepted GPS data from another agency showing that, before it was stopped, the vehicle had been moving on state-owned land. For the Council this was enough. It did not separately discuss the "single production area" argument. Paragraph 3 of Article 24 of Instruction No 996 of the Minister of Finance, for its part, directly prohibits moving goods without a waybill between territorially separate units of an enterprise.
Release from the sanction was also refused. Under paragraph 7 of Article 269, the authority may release a bona fide taxpayer if the violation was caused by the taxpayer's error or ignorance. The taxpayer, however, could not prove this. The materials also noted that at the monitoring stage the company had refused to give an explanation.
One argument that remained open
The company asked to see the GPS data and the primary material behind it. The decision does not show any answer to this request. Paragraph 2 of Article 96 of the General Administrative Code prohibits basing a decision on a circumstance that has not been examined in the manner established by law. If the authority relies on another agency's data, request access to it in writing — this is an issue a court can review.
What to check
- Whether goods move between your own sites along a route that goes beyond your property or licensed area (a public road, state-owned or someone else's plot). If so, issue a transportation waybill for every trip — even without a supply.
- Whether you have a cadastral map of the route: which plot the road crosses and who owns it.
- Give your explanation in writing at the monitoring stage. This is the first and cheapest opportunity to submit evidence in time.
2. The stocktake fine: how it is calculated and why it is not "209%"
What happened
A stocktake carried out by the tax authority revealed two things: goods that were not recorded in the accounts and had no primary document, and a shortage — less stock than the book balance. The taxpayer disputed two points. First, the amount of unrecorded goods in the draft report increased several times over in the final report. Second, in the taxpayer's view, a 209% mark-up had been applied to the shortage instead of the roughly 108% established by the audit. The taxpayer asked for a "reasonable" mark-up of 65–70%.
What the Code says
- Paragraph 4 of Article 286: where inventory items are found that are unrecorded and have no primary tax document, the fine is 50% of their market value as at the time they are found.
- Paragraph 9 of Article 286: a shortage is treated as a supply made at market price at the time it is discovered. If it was revealed by a stocktake of the tax authority, an additional fine of 10% of the market value applies.
- Paragraph 11 of Article 8: a shortage is a deficit of inventory items or fixed assets found by comparison with the accounting records, including one found by a stocktake.
Example (a hypothetical company)
In this case the market value of the shortage was calculated as follows: cost × (1 + mark-up) × 1.18 (VAT). The same method applied to a hypothetical Example LLC:
- The stocktake revealed unrecorded goods with a market value of GEL 20 000. Fine: 20 000 × 50% = GEL 10 000.
- The cost of the shortage is GEL 10 000, and the weighted average mark-up established by the audit is 100%. Market value of the shortage: 10 000 × 2 × 1.18 = GEL 23 600. Fine: 23 600 × 10% = GEL 2 360. In addition, this GEL 23 600 is treated as a supply and is subject to tax.
This shows where the "209%" came from. In the case the coefficient was 2.0886 × 1.18, that is, a mark-up of 108.86% and VAT together. The mark-up was not doubled; the product includes VAT. In our example the same product is 2.36, and that does not mean a mark-up of 136%.
Why it failed
- Comparing the draft with the final report. The draft showed cost, whereas the fine is calculated from market value — these are different bases. Moreover, before the final report part of the goods moved from unrecorded to recorded, and part the other way round. The tables were sent to the taxpayer before the report with a request for a written position, but the taxpayer submitted no comments.
- A "reasonable" mark-up. The mark-up was established by product group, on the basis of sales data. The general 65–70% was not backed by evidence; moreover, in the taxpayer's own accounting records the average mark-up was higher than the one established by the audit.
What to check
- The 2% threshold. Under subparagraph "ა" of paragraph 10 of Article 286, the sanctions of paragraphs 4 and 9 do not apply if the unrecorded surplus or the shortage does not exceed 2% of recorded items of the same kind. So check the result by type of goods, not only in total.
- Voluntary reporting. Under subparagraph "ბ" of the same paragraph, the sanction does not apply if, before the stocktake or audit begins, you reflected the surplus or shortage in your reporting or notified the tax authority: the surplus as a benefit, the shortage as a supply. The best moment for this is your own annual stocktake.
- Tables of the draft report. When the audit sends you tables before the report, reply in writing on each item: which goods are recorded, why, and by which document. At the dispute stage, general disagreement will no longer change the figure.
- Disputing the mark-up. If you disagree with the audit's mark-up, submit your own calculation by product group, based on sales documents.
Practical conclusion
Both Article 286 sanctions are formal. The waybill fine does not require a supply, and the stocktake fine is calculated from market value and comes out much larger than cost. In both cases the taxpayer lost for the same reason: a general argument without specific evidence. A route map, a waybill for every trip, a stocktake reconciled by type of goods and a timely reply to the draft report — this is the minimum that will keep you out of such a dispute.
This is a summary of dispute practice and does not replace advice on a specific case. A detailed analysis of both decisions is available in our disputes database: https://ai.eaudit.ge/davebi/
Basis: Tax Code of Georgia — Articles 8 (paragraph 11), 136 (paragraph 4), 269 (paragraphs 7, 8), 286 (paragraphs 1, 2, 4, 9, 10), current edition (matsne.gov.ge); Instruction approved by Order No 996 of the Minister of Finance of 31.12.2010 — Article 24 (matsne.gov.ge); General Administrative Code — Article 96 (matsne.gov.ge); published decisions of the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia, October 2026 (infohub.rs.ge).
We cover tax audits and dispute proceedings in depth in the course "Tax and Financial Analysis of a Company in Excel": https://eaudit.ge/index.php?newsid=347
📞 Assessment of a waybill or stocktake fine dispute: 598 21 27 01
Need tax, accounting or legal advice? 👉 Request a consultation — leave us your number and we will call you back.