When a company keeps no item-by-item inventory records, or does not submit its records to the audit at all, the Revenue Service calculates its income instead. This is often followed by a second step: the balance derived from a cash flow analysis, whose use the company cannot explain, is treated as the director's salary — with income tax, a fine and penalty interest.
In early October 2026 the Revenue Service considered three such cases: two restaurants and a scrap metal trader. In two cases the appeal was dismissed; in the third it was partly upheld — but only after the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia had sent the case back for reconsideration. Taken together, the three show clearly which arguments work in this type of dispute and which do not.
A detailed analysis of all three decisions is available in our dispute database — ai.eaudit.ge/davebi.
What the issue is
The audit asks two questions. First, how much income there was if the records cannot show it. Second, where the money went that should have remained in the company as the difference between income and documented expenses. The first question is answered by the indirect method, the second by recharacterising the transaction: the balance is deemed received by the director and taxed as salary.
What the law says
Article 73(5) of the Tax Code: "The tax authority may determine a person's tax liabilities using indirect methods (on the basis of comparing the value of assets, operating income and expenses, information about the person with another tax period of its activity or with data on another similar taxpayer, as well as analysing other similar information): ა) if the person has no accounting documentation or the object of taxation cannot be established from the accounting documentation; …"
In other words, the method applies in two situations: when there are no records, and when records exist but the taxable object cannot be established from them. The second situation is more common, and many people overlook it: you have accounting software, but if it shows goods only by supplier, the taxable object cannot be established from it.
Subparagraph "ბ" of paragraph 9 of the same Article: the tax authority may, "having regard to the form and substance of a business transaction, change its characterisation if the form of the transaction does not match its substance".
Paragraph 4 of the same Article: "If any amount is used in the interests of a particular person, that amount shall be deemed to have been received by that person."
These provisions are joined by Article 101 — salary means "any remuneration or benefit received as a result of employment" — and Article 154, under which the duty to withhold tax lies with whoever pays the salary, i.e. the company. Expenses are subject to a strict rule: "all expenses must be supported by documents" (Article 105(2)).
What the practice says
Restaurant 1: income counted in bottles (Order N 21665, 02.10.2026)
A restaurant founded in August 2024 recorded its purchases in its accounting software only by counterparty. The audit found that this made it "impossible to identify by type the products received, used and remaining in stock" and applied the indirect method: it counted the bottles of soft drinks purchased and, using data from similar establishments, determined how many drinks go with one set menu and what the average menu price is. According to the appeal, one GEL 300 menu was assumed for every 10 bottles — 27,754 bottles produced income of GEL 832,620.
The cash flow analysis left a cash balance of GEL 490,335 at the end of the period (gross: GEL 612,918), which was taxed as the director's salary. The total assessment was GEL 353,809.
The taxpayer argued that 16,360 empty bottles had been returned under waybills, that drinks were also sold separately and as takeaway, that a GEL 300 bill is economically unrealistic for delivery sales, and that expenses should have grown along with income. The Revenue Service did not assess these arguments one by one and dismissed the appeal because no evidence displacing the facts had been submitted. The argument about the founder's "contributed capital" (GEL 161,665) failed too — only GEL 7,800 was confirmed through the bank, and no partners' resolution was submitted.
Restaurant 2: no records submitted at all (Order N 22033, 06.10.2026)
The second restaurant submitted no records to the audit at all. Income was established from cash register, payment terminal and bank account data, while only documented purchases, payments to the budget and declared salaries were counted as expenses. The balance at the end of the period came to GEL 4,744,820 (gross) — it was characterised as the directors' salary and income tax of GEL 948,964 was assessed, exactly 20% of that amount. Including VAT and property tax, the total assessment was GEL 2,612,733.
The appellant asked for the balance to be reduced by the partners' capital contributions. The argument failed for one reason: as the audit department explained, capital contributions had not been taken into account in the cash flow calculation "either on the inflow side or on the expense side". What did not enter the calculation of the balance cannot reduce it either. As to "other expenses", for which the appellant was still looking for documents, the authority noted that no evidence had been submitted either during the audit or in the dispute.
Scrap metal: 75% for expenses in the second round (N 13853 → №27708/2/2026 → N 21666)
A scrap metal trading company bought material from individuals without purchase acts. The audit established the purchase cost by category "using audited purchase prices" and assessed the 3% tax on it — on scrap metal bought from an individual without a waybill, this tax is withheld by the buyer (Articles 133³ and 154). The remaining disposable amount was treated as the director's salary. The assessment was GEL 199,679.
In June the Revenue Service dismissed the appeal. The company turned to the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia: the audit report did not show which companies' data had been used to set the "audited prices", and by the company's calculation only about 60% of income had been counted as expenses. In September the Council annulled the order and sent the case back: the calculation using audited prices "requires further examination".
On reconsideration, the Revenue Service instructed the audit to "take 75% of the income received into account as expenses" and reduce the liability. This approach had been proposed by the appellant on the basis of a Revenue Service situational guide. An important detail: this is not yet the final result — the audit recalculates the reduced amount, and the order can be appealed. The margin argument and the suppliers' explanations were not assessed separately.
What does not work and what does
Does not work:
- a general "there was a shortcoming, but not of this size" — without figures;
- "we will submit the documents later" — the authority assesses only what has been submitted;
- reducing the balance by a capital contribution if the audit did not count that contribution as an inflow;
- "repayment of a debt" to the founder without bank confirmation and a partners' resolution;
- a valid argument not backed by figures — returned containers, separate sales.
Works:
- disputing the share of expenses when purchases cannot be established from documents;
- demanding the source of the comparative data or the "audited prices" — an undisclosed method became the ground for sending the case back at the Ministry's Council;
- using both stages: in the scrap metal case the outcome changed precisely in the second round.
Practical conclusions
- Keep inventory records by item — what came in, what was sold and what is left; records by supplier are not enough.
- Record every contribution and loan from the founder through the bank and with a partners' resolution — on the same day.
- Draw up a purchase act for every purchase from an individual.
- If the audit has taxed the balance as salary, first find out what entered the cash flow as income and what as expenses. Build your counter-argument only after that.
- Turn every argument into a figure: how many bottles, how many lari, what share. The authority will have to respond to exactly that calculation.
Risks
Taxing the balance as salary is the most expensive step: the amount is treated as paid out net, so income tax is calculated on the grossed-up amount, and the fine under Article 275 and penalty interest are added on top. In the second restaurant's case the income tax alone was GEL 948,964, and the total assessment exceeded GEL 2.6 million. Conversely, a single document — a purchase act, a bank deposit, a partners' resolution — often closes a whole episode.
We cover this topic in depth in our course "Tax and Financial Analysis of a Company in Excel" — in the part on the tax audit report and the conduct of disputes.
Sources
- Tax Code of Georgia — Article 73, paragraphs 4, 5 ("ა") and 9 ("ბ"); Articles 101, 105 (paragraph 2), 133³ and 154; current version — matsne.gov.ge
- Revenue Service Order N 21665, 02.10.2026 — infohub.rs.ge
- Revenue Service Order N 22033, 06.10.2026 — infohub.rs.ge
- Decision of the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia №27708/2/2026, 11.09.2026 — infohub.rs.ge
- Revenue Service Order N 21666, 02.10.2026 — infohub.rs.ge
- Situational Guide №0256 "Deduction of Expenses from Gross Income" — infohub.rs.ge
Need tax, accounting or legal advice? 👉 Request a consultation — leave your number and we will get back to you.