Elit Audit
ქართულიРусский

Market price of apartments in construction: what tax dispute practice shows

This is a translation of an article published in Georgian on 09.10.2026. It describes the rules as they stood on that date. Where the translation and the Georgian original differ, the Georgian text prevails; provisions of Georgian law are binding only in Georgian. Subparagraph letters are given as in the Georgian text of the law.

When a construction company sells an apartment or commercial space to its founder, director or another related party, both the transaction price and the taxation of the price difference may be challenged during an audit. If the authority concludes that the transaction was made below the market price, it determines the tax liability on the basis of the market price.

In such a case the issue is not just the valuation of the apartment. You need to establish what data the authority used to set the market price, which period it used for comparison and how it assessed the price difference. For the director, the founder, the accountant and the CFO these questions are connected, but each has to be checked separately.

The approaches discussed below are based on tax dispute decisions from 2024–2026. The practice shows both the arguments of the audit and when a claim remains unsubstantiated and when a specific circumstance needs to be re-examined.

For this article we processed hundreds of construction-related tax disputes, including court decisions; we studied the decisions on market price in detail, and the conclusions follow from that practice. A detailed review of the disputes and their analysis is available on our website — ai.eaudit.ge/davebi.

How the authority establishes the market price

In the practice reviewed, the audit does not rely solely on the price stated in the sale and purchase agreement. It uses Public Registry information, mortgage agreements, comparable transactions of companies engaged in similar activities and data on apartments sold in the same or nearby buildings.

Comparable data may also be found in the company's own transactions. The decisions include cases where prices of apartments sold in the same building were used. So when you assess your own sales, pay attention to the transactions with independent buyers as well: their terms matter for comparison with the disputed price.

Another line of the audit is comparing the documents with the amounts actually received. The authority compares the contract value, Public Registry data, the accounting records and bank receipts. The amount stated in the contract cannot serve as justification of the price if other documents show different income.

In the cases reviewed, where the taxpayer had no valuation document or the valuations did not match, the tax authority obtained a valuation through the relevant department of the Revenue Service or through the National Forensics Bureau. The practical question is what the valuation used is based on and with what evidence the taxpayer challenges it.

What is taxed

In the cases reviewed, valuing a transaction with a related party at market price also affects the VAT taxable amount. The audit calculates VAT from the market price and adjusts the corresponding liability. Taxing the price difference, however, requires a further assessment.

Under subparagraph "ა" of Article 98¹(4) of the TCG, a transaction carried out by an enterprise with a related party is treated as a distribution of profit where the relevant conditions are met. The party must be one that is not subject to profit tax on the objects of taxation provided for in the first and 3rd paragraphs of Article 97 of the TCG; the transaction price must differ from the market price, and the relationship must affect the outcome of the transaction.

Where an apartment is sold below the market price, the amount of distributed profit is the difference between the market price of the transaction and the income received or receivable, if the market price exceeds that income. In the practice reviewed, it is exactly this difference that is treated as distributed profit and subjected to profit tax.

Merely mentioning the founder's status therefore cannot replace a full legal justification. The assessment must also cover the conditions set by the provision: the tax status of the person, the price deviation and the effect of the relationship on the outcome of the transaction.

For a transaction with a director, the audit may take a different approach. Article 73(9) of the TCG entitles the authority, having regard to the form and substance of a transaction, to change its characterisation if the form does not match the substance. In the cases reviewed, the authority uses this approach to recharacterise the price difference as salary paid to the director and taxes it with income tax.

This describes the audit's approach. In individual cases the characterisation itself becomes the subject of the dispute — how the difference should be treated given the substance of the specific transaction. Accordingly, both the amount of the market price and the basis for taxing the difference identified using that price may be disputed.

What does not work in a dispute

In the practice reviewed, general claims that the audit should not have applied the market price to the apartments were not upheld. Simply pointing to the price agreed in the contract does not answer the comparable data used by the authority or the inconsistencies it identified.

When preparing such a dispute, you need a specific objection: which data you disagree with, why the transactions are not comparable, or which period's price should be assessed. This is a working direction that follows from the practice. Repeating general dissatisfaction cannot replace a substantive examination of the evidence.

Release from sanctions is a separate matter. Under Article 269(7) of the TCG, the tax authority, the dispute resolution body or the court may release a bona fide taxpayer from a sanction if the offence was caused by the taxpayer's mistake or lack of knowledge.

In the cases reviewed, requests for release from sanctions were not granted. The decisions focus on specific factual and legal circumstances that would confirm the taxpayer's legal error.

So in a request concerning the sanction, too, describe exactly what the error consisted of and which circumstance supports your position. A general reference to good faith cannot substitute for this justification.

What leads to a re-examination

A re-examination is triggered by a specific, verifiable question. In barter cases, such a question is the point in time at which the market price of the real estate should be determined. The decisions include instructions to determine the price as at the date the contract was concluded; for other transactions, attention is paid to clarifying the time of supply.

So in your appeal, do not just contest the final amount of the valuation. If the period used is disputed, link this claim to the contract and to the documents of the relevant transaction. This makes it clear what the authority has to examine and why this circumstance may affect the calculation.

Additional documentary evidence also matters. In the practice reviewed, the taxpayer is given a deadline to submit material supporting its arguments, and the authority is instructed to examine it. When you receive such an instruction, read carefully exactly which document is requested and by when it must be submitted.

An expert examination also matters for clarifying the market price. The practice includes instructions to submit the agreement on commissioning a forensic expert examination and to examine further the opinion prepared on that basis. The valuation evidence must relate precisely to the disputed property and to the point in time being valued.

A re-examination is not a win. Further examination of an issue does not in itself confirm a reduction of the tax. In the decisions reviewed, an adjustment depends on the results of the examination and on the existence of proper grounds. So when assessing a decision, clearly separate the instruction to examine from the outcome, which can only be established through further review.

What you should have before the audit

Based on the practice reviewed, prepare in advance material that clearly presents the transaction price and its terms:

  • A documented reason for the lower price. If an apartment or space is sold more cheaply than in comparable transactions, keep the documents that support this difference. The explanation and the evidence must be connected.
  • Comparable transactions. Organise the data on sales in the same building and in the relevant period, including contracts with independent buyers. When comparing prices, it must be clear which transactions you are using and why.
  • Consistency between the contract price and bank receipts. Check how the amounts received relate to the contract and the accounting records. Any existing inconsistency must be explained with documents.
  • Where needed, an independent valuation or a forensic expert examination. Decide in advance which property and which point in time the price must be established for. The valuation material must answer the specific disputed question.

Reviewing these documents together helps you see how consistent the company's position is. If the contract, the receipts and the price justification are not connected, merely collecting them will not produce a complete argument.

The practical aim of the preparation is to be able to explain how the transaction price was formed and what evidence supports it. If a dispute is already under way, link the same material to the specific claim: which circumstance the authority should re-examine and what the submitted document confirms.

This is a summary of public practice and does not replace advice on a specific case.

We offer a consultation: we will discuss how an audit might determine the market price of your transaction, what evidence you need and how to prepare for an audit or a dispute.

Basis: Article 98¹(4), Article 73(9) and Article 269(7) of the TCG — as amended on 30.09.2026; published decisions of the dispute resolution councils of the Revenue Service and under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia (infohub.rs.ge). The number, date and amount of any specific case are not given; the general conclusions on practice are based on more than one independent dispute.

📋 Case or risk assessment: ai.eaudit.ge/dava · 📞 598 21 27 01

Need tax, accounting or legal advice? 👉 Request a consultation — leave your number and we will get back to you.

← All articles

Elit Audit

Talk to us

Tell us which service you need — we will discuss the details together.

+995 598 21 27 01mail@eaudit.ge
Lublianis St. 13b, Digomi, Tbilisi, Georgia
Contact form (in Georgian)