At the end of the year, shops carry out a stocktake. A shortage is almost always found: some items were stolen, some were damaged, some were recorded incorrectly. The accountant's first question is whether this is taxed.
For a shop with open shelves, the answer is often favourable: a small shortage, up to a certain threshold, is not treated as a shortage for tax purposes at all. In this article we look at who the rule applies to, how the threshold is calculated and where mistakes are made.
What the legal basis is
Under subparagraph "ა" of paragraph 9 of Article 73 of the Tax Code, when determining a tax liability, the tax authority has the right to disregard business transactions that have no material economic effect.
A practical application of this rule is a small shortage of non-food goods in shops. Up to a certain threshold, such a shortage is regarded as an immaterial loss and is not treated as a shortage for taxation purposes.
Who it applies to: the "open warehouse" shop
The rule applies to a shop (market, supermarket, hypermarket) where non-food goods are sold on the "open warehouse" principle. All four conditions must be met together:
- customer entrances and exits are identified;
- goods are placed where customers can reach them: on shelves, counters and other storage units;
- customers choose the goods themselves or with the help of a cashier-consultant;
- purchases and sales are recorded using barcodes and software, so that both the cost price and the sales proceeds can be seen.
If the goods are behind the counter and only the seller hands them to you, or if recording is not done by barcode, the rule does not apply.
Which goods it does not cover
"Non-food goods" do not include:
- food (a separate rule applies to it);
- excise goods, wine and beverages subject to labelling;
- pharmaceutical products and food supplements;
- appliances, equipment, tools, furniture and textiles for any purpose;
- clothing, footwear, garments and accessories;
- cosmetics and perfumery.
In practice, the rule covers hygiene products, household chemicals, detergents, tableware, stationery, toys, souvenirs and similar everyday goods.
How the threshold is calculated
The threshold for immaterial loss is 0,5% of the value (excluding VAT) of non-food goods sold from the shops during the previous calendar year. Goods taxed as a shortage are also counted within this amount.
The threshold applies to the total of all shortages found during the current year, and only to shortages of non-food goods.
Example
Last year, a chain of shops sold hygiene products and household chemicals worth GEL 900 000 (excluding VAT). The threshold for the current year is 900 000 × 0,5% = GEL 4 500.
The December stocktake revealed:
- a shortage of household chemicals — GEL 3 000;
- a shortage of household appliances — GEL 1 200.
The GEL 3 000 of chemicals fits within the threshold and is not treated as a shortage. The GEL 1 200 of appliances, however, is taxed, because appliances are excluded from the rule and the threshold does not apply to them, even though GEL 1 500 still remains within the threshold.
New business
If you do not have a full previous year (for example, you registered in the middle of the year), the threshold is calculated monthly until the end of the first full year. The basis is 0,5% of the non-food goods sold from registration up to and including the month in which the shortage was found, reduced by the threshold already used in previous months.
Year-end recalculation: the 10% rule
The threshold is calculated on the previous year's figures, so at the end of the year it is checked how much sales of non-food goods have changed:
- if they increased by 10% or more, the threshold is calculated on the current year's turnover, and the shortage already taxed that falls within the increased threshold is reduced by correcting the returns for the relevant months;
- if they decreased by 10% or more, the threshold is reduced, and the shortage not yet taxed that falls outside the threshold is reflected in the December returns.
If the change is less than 10%, no recalculation is made, even if the threshold based on the new turnover would come out slightly higher.
In other words, after a good year part of the taxed shortage may come back to you, while after a bad year additional tax may arise in December. That is why you should compare annual turnover before the December return.
Pitfalls
1. If the thief is known, the rule does not work
The rule covers a shortage where the person who committed the theft or unlawful use has not been identified. If the damage or compensation has been charged to someone, for example an employee, the rule does not apply to that shortage.
2. Wholesale from the "open warehouse"
If you also sell wholesale from the same building, wholesale goods must not be included in the "open warehouse". Otherwise, the wholesale and retail flows will be mixed up.
3. VAT-taxable and exempt goods together
If the shortage includes both types of goods, VAT-taxable goods are counted first within the threshold. This order is also kept in the annual recalculation.
4. The threshold applies to the category, not to total turnover
The 0,5% is calculated only on sales of non-food goods, excluding the turnover of food, appliances and other excluded goods. If you calculate the threshold on total revenue, it will come out inflated and you will avoid tax without justification.
Practical conclusion
- Check whether the shop meets all four "open warehouse" conditions, especially barcode recording.
- Split the stocktake results by category of goods: non-food (covered by the rule), food and excluded goods.
- Calculate the threshold as the previous year's non-food sales (excluding VAT) × 0,5%.
- Before the December return, compare annual turnover: a change of ±10% triggers a recalculation.
- If the person responsible for the shortage has been identified or compensation has been charged, do not apply the rule.
Basis: subparagraph "ა" of paragraph 9 of Article 73 of the Tax Code; the methodological guideline "On not treating immaterial losses of non-food goods revealed at retail outlets as a shortage", approved by Order No. 26094 of the Head of the Revenue Service of 13 October 2022. The guideline applies to shortages revealed from 1 January 2022.
Is a stocktake coming up and you are not sure which shortage is taxed? 📞 Tax advice and analysis of stocktake results: 598 21 27 01
Need tax, accounting or legal advice? 👉 Request a consultation — leave your number and we will get back to you.