Elit Audit
ქართულიРусский

Tax Assessed by the Indirect Method: Which Arguments Help the Taxpayer

This is a translation of an article published in Georgian on 17.09.2026. It describes the rules as they stood on that date. Where the translation and the Georgian original differ, the Georgian text prevails; provisions of Georgian law are binding only in Georgian. Subparagraph letters are given as in the Georgian text of the law.

The indirect method is one of the most contested tools of a tax audit: the authority calculates turnover or income not from documents but on the basis of mark-up, market price, data of a similar enterprise or the growth of assets. In this article we look at what the Tax Code says and, based on dispute practice, at what helps the taxpayer in such a dispute.

What the Tax Code says

Under paragraph 5 of Article 73 of the Tax Code, the tax authority has the right to determine a person's tax liabilities using indirect methods — on the basis of an analysis of the size of assets, operating income and expenses, comparison with data for another tax period or of other similar taxpayers, and other similar information. The grounds for this are:

  • subparagraph "ა": the person has no accounting records, or the object of taxation cannot be determined from the accounting records;
  • subparagraph "ბ": more than one of the following conditions — an unjustified increase in assets; expenses exceeding declared income; two or more offences identified in the audited period; a material difference between declared data and data recorded through ongoing control.

What practice shows

Of the 70 decisions we processed (most of them from 2026), 5 ended in the taxpayer's favour, 48 were partially upheld and 17 were dismissed. On this topic, "partially upheld" usually means that the case was sent back for re-examination; whether the amount will be reduced is not yet known at this stage.

The conclusions below are not based on a single case — each recurs in several disputes.

What helps the taxpayer

1. Checking the grounds for applying the method. First, establish which fact the authority relies on when it says that there are no records or that the object of taxation cannot be determined from documents. If no such fact appears in the tax audit report, the main question in the dispute is the ground under paragraph 5 of Article 73, not the figures. However, the mere existence of accounting software does not rule out this ground: the authority checks whether it actually makes it possible to determine the object.

2. Arithmetic. In the cases that ended in the taxpayer's favour, a simple calculation often proved decisive: how much the method changed the declared turnover, and what share the disputed volume represents in the documented turnover. If the difference is insignificant, the need to apply the method is called into question.

3. A specific error, not general criticism of the method. What works is showing a specific error in the authority's calculation: an atypical base document, official benchmark data (for example, the price in a customs declaration) and an alternative calculation based on the authority's own assumptions. In market price disputes, also check which source was used, as of which date and at which exchange rate.

4. Independent expert examination. Verbal criticism of the market price or mark-up does not change the assessment. An opinion of an independent expert is stronger, and it is better to commission it before the dispute begins.

What does not help the taxpayer

1. A general statement that the mark-up is "unrealistic". General argument about the percentage, without specific data, did not produce a result.

2. A merely declaratory reference to an "agency scheme". If the contracts and cash flows do not confirm an agency relationship, or the taxpayer reported its full turnover in its own return, this argument does not work.

3. Failure to submit documents at the re-examination stage. Partial upholding of an appeal usually provides a time limit (often 15 days) for submitting documents. If that time limit is missed, or a spreadsheet is submitted in a form the authority cannot access, the recalculation confirms the original assessment.

Release from sanctions

Paragraph 7 of Article 269 of the Tax Code gives the tax authority, the dispute resolution body or the court the right to release a bona fide taxpayer from a sanction if the offence was caused by the taxpayer's error or lack of knowledge. This request must be raised in the very first appeal and be based on specific circumstances; a general economic explanation has usually not proved sufficient.

Practical tips

  • As soon as you receive the tax audit report, establish on which ground under paragraph 5 of Article 73 the indirect method was applied, and which fact confirms that ground.
  • Calculate the share of the disputed volume in the documented turnover.
  • Prepare an alternative calculation based on the authority's assumptions, and name an official benchmark source.
  • Commission an expert examination before the dispute begins.
  • At the re-examination stage, do not miss the time limit, and submit the spreadsheet in a form the authority can access.

Sources

  • Tax Code of Georgia, Article 73 (paragraph 5, subparagraphs "ა" and "ბ") and Article 269 (paragraph 7) — current version.
  • Elit Audit dispute cards (70 decisions, count as of 17.09.2026). For reasons of ethics and confidentiality, we do not cite specific cases.

This article is a general summary of practice and does not replace an individual analysis of a specific case. 📞 Review and appeal of assessments made by the indirect method: 598 21 27 01

Need tax, accounting or legal advice? 👉 Request a consultation — leave your number and we will get back to you.

← All articles

Elit Audit

Talk to us

Tell us which service you need — we will discuss the details together.

+995 598 21 27 01mail@eaudit.ge
Lublianis St. 13b, Digomi, Tbilisi, Georgia
Contact form (in Georgian)