Elit Audit
ქართულიРусский

The Council ordered an examination: how to frame the request in your appeal

This is a translation of an article published in Georgian on 08.10.2026. It describes the rules as they stood on that date. Where the translation and the Georgian original differ, the Georgian text prevails; provisions of Georgian law are binding only in Georgian. Subparagraph letters are given as in the Georgian text of the law.

You have received a decision on your appeal, and it contains an instruction for further examination? That does not yet mean the disputed amount has been reduced or written off. When assessing the decision, what matters is what exactly the Council decided and which issue it instructed the lower authority to examine.

In a number of cases of the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia the same outcome recurs: the lower authority is instructed to examine a specific issue further. The main point of this practice is also useful when preparing an appeal. The request should ideally show not only the final result you want, but also which evidence and which issue need to be re-examined.

What recurs in the practice reviewed

Subparagraph "ბ" of paragraph 1 of Article 304 of the Tax Code provides for partial satisfaction of an appeal, which in the practice reviewed often takes the form of an instruction to examine a specific issue.

According to the summary provided, what several cases have in common is an instruction to examine a specific issue. The other parts of the decisions are not all the same. Partial annulment does not occur in every case reviewed. Nor is referral back for reconsideration the common outcome of each of them.

The general conclusion should therefore stay narrow: the Council instructs the lower authority to carry out an examination. A broader conclusion — that in all such cases the same procedure follows or the same final outcome is reached — is not supported by the material provided.

This distinction calls for practical care when reading the text. An instruction to examine, partial annulment and reconsideration should not be used as interchangeable terms. A particular decision should be described by the action it actually sets out.

The limits of the conclusion and how to describe the decision

In these cases the Council does not set an amount; it orders an examination. This is our conclusion from reading the operative parts, not a verbatim quotation from the decision. That the amount was written off is not supported by this material.

In your working summary of the outcome, first identify what the authority was instructed to do. If the decision sets out another action as well, describe it separately. Then compare: what did you ask to be examined, and what was the authority instructed to examine? A summary of general practice cannot replace the text of the specific decision.

How to frame the request

The practical direction of the source is a request to re-examine documentary evidence on a specific issue. Compared with a request simply to cancel the assessment, this wording makes clear what the appellant wants checked.

In the working draft of the appeal it helps to link together the disputed issue, the related document and the request for examination. This is a recommendation for preparing the text, not a description of a form prescribed by law.

First describe which issue your objection concerns. Then state which documentary evidence you ask to be examined. Finally, set out exactly which issue you want that examination to clarify. This order of the request follows the practical direction identified in the source.

If your working text describes only general dissatisfaction, go back to the specific issue. What should the authority re-examine? Which document does the request relate to? Reflect the answers to these questions in the substance of the request, and do not stop at a list of documents.

A working wording for the request

An editorial template, not a quotation from a real appeal:

"I request that you re-examine the documentary evidence referred to in connection with the specific issue described in the appeal and, on the basis of that examination, consider the relevant disputed issue."

This wording is a working framework to be filled in. In place of the general words it should show the specific issue and document of your own case. Copying the template unchanged cannot replace preparing the substance of the appeal.

The purpose of the example is to show the direction of the request: the documentary evidence and the specific issue to be examined should be linked to each other. The template does not represent a form approved by the Council, nor does it predetermine the outcome.

Practical conclusion

When preparing an appeal, put the main emphasis on the specific issue and on the request to re-examine documentary evidence. Once the decision is issued, read separately what action the authority was instructed to take.

This summary of practice is no substitute for the text of the law. The confirmed outcome in the cases reviewed is an instruction to examine; that the amount was written off is not supported by this material.

This is a summary of public practice and does not replace advice on a specific case.

Basis: paragraph 1 of Article 304 of the Tax Code of Georgia; published practice of the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia.

📞 Review of the request in your appeal: 598 21 27 01

Need tax, accounting or legal advice? 👉 Request a consultation — leave your number and we will call you back.

← All articles

Elit Audit

Talk to us

Tell us which service you need — we will discuss the details together.

+995 598 21 27 01mail@eaudit.ge
Lublianis St. 13b, Digomi, Tbilisi, Georgia
Contact form (in Georgian)