When the tax audit report arrives and a fine has been assessed, an accountant's first thought is almost always the same: "It was a mistake; we did nothing on purpose." Paragraph 7 of Article 269 of the Tax Code of Georgia answers exactly this intuition.
For this article we read 41 decisions published on infohub.rs.ge — of the Revenue Service, the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia and the courts (the list is at the end of the article). The picture is this: "I didn't know" and "we didn't do it on purpose" do not by themselves lift a fine; the fine was lifted where the error was visible from the facts. On penalty interest, in 2026 the two bodies act differently. At the end, separately from the law and the facts of the decisions, we offer the author's practical recommendations.
What exactly the rule says
"The tax authority/the dispute resolution body or the court may release a bona fide taxpayer from a sanction provided for by this Code if the offence was caused by the taxpayer's error/lack of knowledge." (Tax Code, 269.7)
Three words decide everything:
- "May" — this is discretion, not an automatic relief. In its refusal orders the Revenue Service often confines itself to one standard sentence: it "does not consider it appropriate" to apply 269.7.
- "Bona fide" — as the Revenue Service interprets it, good faith means the person's subjective attitude towards the act they committed and is linked to the error they made. When lifting the fine, the Council under the Ministry of Finance also assessed facts about the taxpayer's conduct — returns, payment, cooperation during the audit (see below).
- "Error/lack of knowledge" — the bodies look for the "area of legal error": the person misjudges the legal nature of the act and its consequences. Negligence does not count: the Council under the Ministry of Finance requires the appellant to show that the breach was caused "not by their negligence" but happened despite due care; and the Supreme Court held carelessness to be a form of fault that rules out good faith.
The rule does not name penalty interest separately — it speaks of a "sanction", and under the Code penalty interest is a tax sanction (270.2, 272.1). What follows from this in practice — below.
Where it works: three configurations
1. The error is visible from the facts — and the other side confirms it too. In four of the cases reviewed, the Council under the Ministry of Finance lifted the fine for operating without VAT registration, although the Revenue Service had not upheld the appeal. In all four the Council listed the same kind of facts: small business status; a cash register, a POS terminal or a bank account; cooperation during the audit; the liability was established from the taxpayer's own documents, and no grounds for the indirect method arose. In three cases, filed returns and paid income tax were added to this. These circumstances were confirmed at the hearing by the representative of the Audit Department — in three cases it was recorded that the breach "may have been caused by the taxpayer's error". The Revenue Service also lifted a fine when the audit representative accepted that the amounts entered in a box of the return were a clerical error.
2. The taxpayer does not dispute the assessment and explains the breach by not knowing the rule. In two such cases — one with an individual and one with an individual entrepreneur — the Revenue Service lifted both the fine and the penalty interest. In both, the appellant agreed with the tax assessed. Payment is reflected differently in the cases: in one, the body itself noted that the tax had been paid and focused on the appellant's argument that the breach was caused by not knowing the legislative rules; in the other, payment is the appellant's statement ("states that the tax has been paid") — it does not appear in the body's reasoning as a separately established fact; there the appellant also pointed out that they kept the books on their own, without the services of a qualified person, and the body concluded that they had acted under an excusable error. This is no guarantee: in other cases, where the assessment was accepted and financial hardship was cited, the sanction stayed (see below).
3. The rule is clearly ambiguous — but the bar is high. Two decisions of the Kutaisi City Court and one ruling of the Supreme Court apply the same criterion: a taxpayer may be mistaken in good faith about the substance of the law if the rule, "because of its clearly ambiguous and equivocal content", allows a different interpretation. In both City Court cases the claim was dismissed — the criterion concerns the ambiguity of the rule, not how convincing the taxpayer's reading was.
Where it does not work
1. No books were kept, or the books did not reflect real data. The Council under the Ministry of Finance refused to apply 269.7 in two cases where the liability was determined by the indirect method: in one, no accounting records were kept; in the other, the records and accounting software submitted did not reflect real data. In both the Council recorded that the appellant had failed to prove that the breach was not caused by negligence; in the second it added: "not every error is a ground for release from a sanction". As a mirror image, in all four cases where the fine was lifted (the first configuration), the Council noted separately that no grounds for the indirect method had arisen.
2. Financial hardship. The Revenue Service left the sanction in force in three cases where the appellant cited a difficult financial or economic situation; in one of them the Council under the Ministry of Finance repeated the refusal. The reasoning is the same in all three: the appellant does not point to circumstances that would confirm acting "within the area of legal error". The rule assesses the cause of the breach, not the taxpayer's situation: even in the cases where the fine was lifted and the appellant also spoke of financial difficulties, the Council relied on other facts.
3. Only "I didn't know" or "we didn't do it on purpose". One formula recurs in refusal orders: the appellant "does not point to factual and legal circumstances" that would confirm acting within the area of legal error. Citing lack of knowledge, absence of intent or good faith without facts does not pass this test.
Procedure, which is often more important than the argument
What 302.3 says and what happened in two cases. Under 302.3 of the Tax Code, "unless otherwise provided for by this Chapter", the Dispute Resolution Council considers an appeal within the scope of the subject of the dispute appealed at the Revenue Service. In two cases the Council did not consider the 269.7 request because it went beyond the subject of the dispute under review. In one, the request was raised only at the hearing of the Council under the Ministry of Finance; the Council noted that the issue had not been appealed at the Revenue Service and invoked 302.3. In the other, the request was raised in a dispute over the enforcement of an earlier order: the Revenue Service noted that the issue had not been disputed in the original appeal, and the Council — that it could not go beyond the enforcement issue.
Penalty interest: the rule does not exclude it, but in 2026 the two bodies act differently.
- The Revenue Service has a practice of lifting penalty interest under 269.7: in four orders reviewed, penalty interest was lifted too, in three of them together with the fine, for the part accrued "as of the date of this decision". This is not a rule: in other orders of the same Service where penalty interest had also been assessed, the operative part lifts only the fine — including a case where the appellant asked for the "fine/penalty interest" to be lifted.
- In decisions of the Council under the Ministry of Finance published from February to September 2026 we found 13 such cases: the fine was lifted under 269.7, while the Council gave separate reasons for refusing release from penalty interest: penalty interest "in substance represents compensation for the financial loss to the budget caused by late payment of tax, which distinguishes it from the substance of a monetary fine". The Council does not say it has no power to do so — it says it "does not consider it appropriate" to release from penalty interest. This happened even when the appellant had requested in writing that penalty interest be lifted together with the fine; in one case a second appeal on the same penalty interest also ended in refusal. In tax cases of the same year we found no instance of this Council lifting penalty interest (the only exception is a customs dispute), whereas in earlier years decisions of the same Council also include lifting penalty interest. That is, this is the 2026 line, not a direct requirement of the law.
A refusal at the first stage did not prove final in four cases. In all four cases of the first configuration, the Revenue Service did not consider it appropriate to apply 269.7 and did not uphold the appeal; the Council under the Ministry of Finance, however, lifted the fine. The decisive factor turned out to be the facts that the other side also confirmed at the hearing.
One Supreme Court case: review and refusal together. In one case the Supreme Court explained that decisions taken in exercise of the power granted by 269.7 must be subject to full judicial review — but in the same case it upheld the Revenue Service's cassation appeal and dismissed the taxpayer's claim: the taxpayer had acted carelessly, which is a form of fault. In this case the court examined not only the body's decision but also whether there had been an excusable error at all.
In addition: repeat offences and warnings
Under 269.8 of the Tax Code, an offence is deemed to be committed repeatedly if the same act is committed within 12 months of the detection of the previous offence. At the same time, an offence provided for by Article 281 is not deemed to be committed repeatedly if the person committed offences provided for by that same Article on the same day, at territorially separate facilities. And 270.7 of the Tax Code allows a warning instead of a monetary fine for a breach provided for by Articles 273 and 281, paragraph one or paragraph 11 of Article 286, and Articles 288⁵ and 291 — if it has not been committed repeatedly.
Practical conclusion
269.7 is not a "plea for mercy" — it requires you to name facts. In these cases the fine was lifted where it was visible that returns had been filed and tax paid, the liability was established from the taxpayer's own documents, there was cooperation during the audit, and the error — clerical or not knowing the rule — was visible from the facts, often with the other side itself confirming it. Where this could not be shown and the request rested only on lack of knowledge or financial hardship, the sanction stayed.
On penalty interest the picture is split: the Revenue Service lifted it in the four orders reviewed, while at the Council under the Ministry of Finance, under 2026 practice, penalty interest as a rule remains — even when the fine has been lifted.
The author's practical recommendations
This is the author's advice, not a requirement of the law or a rule established by a decision; it is based on the rules and cases described above.
- Put the 269.7 request and the request to lift penalty interest in your very first appeal, in writing and as separate items (above: 302.2 — the scope of the request, 302.3 — the subject of the dispute appealed at the Revenue Service).
- Instead of "it was a mistake", name the facts and back them with documents: returns, payment, bookkeeping, cash register/POS/bank, cooperation during the audit.
- Build your cash plan on the assumption that penalty interest may remain even if the fine is lifted at the Council under the Ministry of Finance.
- If the fine in the report has been increased as a repeat offence, check when the previous breach was detected and whether the case concerns Article 281 breaches on the same day at territorially separate facilities (269.8).
Basis: paragraphs 7 and 8 of Article 269, paragraphs 2 and 7 of Article 270, the first paragraph of Article 272, paragraphs 2 and 3 of Article 302 of the Tax Code (current wording); public decisions of the Revenue Service, the Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia and the courts — list below.
Received a report and facing a fine? Leave your number and we'll call you: ai.eaudit.ge/dava · or call: 598 21 27 01
Correction (26.10.2026): The version of 19.08.2026 stated that in one case penalty interest remained only because its removal was requested at the hearing, orally. The text of the decision does not confirm this: removal of penalty interest was indeed requested at the hearing, but the Council did not discuss penalty interest and gave no reason; in other decisions of the same period, the Council bases its refusal to lift penalty interest on its compensatory nature — also where the request was made in writing. Also corrected: the general statistics (could not be traced back to a source and have been removed), the interpretation of good faith, "the outcome does not change at the second stage" (in four cases it did) the description of the Supreme Court decision, and the Article 281 exception in 269.8; the advice has been separated out as the author's recommendations. Case numbers, dates and amounts have been moved from the text to the list of sources.
Disclaimer
This is a summary of dispute practice, not legal advice on a specific case.
Sources
Law
- Tax Code of Georgia No. 3591 (17.09.2010) — Art. 269 (paragraphs 7, 8), 270 (paragraphs 2, 7), 272 (first paragraph), 302 (paragraphs 2, 3); current wording, publication 247 (from 15.10.2026) — https://matsne.gov.ge/ka/document/view/1043717?publication=247
Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia — fine lifted under 269.7, reasoned refusal of release from penalty interest (13)
- Decision №99701/1/2025 (04.02.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/b2946af8-c522-4ba4-81d7-60e2570ddcf1
- Decision №26370/2/2025 (10.02.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/5e84af84-ff22-42d3-b4b8-2dd6f1effba2
- Decision №26400/2/2025 (16.02.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/c83cabde-223d-4ea6-93fc-def43dadbe6f
- Decision №26648/2/2026 (09.03.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/607e3e98-8345-44cd-85ac-5fdabe71a6bc
- Decision №26647/2/2026 (12.03.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/2b8bff35-9d54-43b4-8b79-a6b15d58b71f
- Decision №26734/2/2026 (31.03.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/9de03c60-020c-47e0-aee2-9d44b8267db5
- Decision №26756/2/2026 (31.03.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/4adc604c-74a8-406f-8917-900709523dd7
- Decision №26854/2/2026 (01.04.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/d1b07b88-da8b-41b0-98d5-06c21b3e9a7a
- Decision №26716/2/2026 (02.04.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/94f2c949-8526-4b4d-b2f4-5fae778c624d
- Decision №27007/2/2026 (01.05.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/59d07a7d-bb03-4a0b-973e-11bdba9a8117
- Decision №27058/2/2026 (29.05.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/6266bb68-0fe8-4f75-b2e9-1a88af316b11
- Decision №27401/2/2026 (02.06.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/c0932f91-0633-4526-bf79-fb1feb59051b
- Decision №27923/2/2026 (16.09.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/8f6e089a-1866-457b-aabc-4c1c93dc196e
Dispute Resolution Council under the Ministry of Finance of Georgia — other decisions
- Decision №26826/2/2026 (06.04.2026) — fine lifted; removal of penalty interest was requested at the hearing, the Council's text contains no reasoning on penalty interest — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/7fd28e26-1fd4-46c6-8f6b-88b0bcfaa8d1
- Decision №27385/2/2026 (24.06.2026) — second appeal on the same penalty interest (after №26716/2/2026), not upheld — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/c56053d3-92d6-4ec5-937b-92aa22f47cfe
- Decision №22538/2/2024 (11.06.2024) — fine and penalty interest lifted — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/9496eced-42cc-438c-8f18-f35558c35cb2
- Decision №24912/2/2025 (17.04.2025) — fine and penalty interest lifted — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/9e4249b7-e568-4383-a622-9236416ac1ca
- Decision №26340/2/2025 (16.01.2026) — customs dispute, penalty interest lifted — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/a494cb7e-5c4c-4cda-bc8c-507e569cbd0a
- Decision №27422/2/2026 (04.08.2026) — no books kept, 269.7 refused — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/deeb551c-fcbb-4dc4-99a5-a95533fab172
- Decision №27814/2/2026 (07.08.2026) — books did not reflect real data, 269.7 refused — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/d1dec671-6154-4f6c-a056-c4e0a18b6cbf
- Decision №28022/2/2026 (05.10.2026) — 269.7 raised only at the hearing, 302.3 — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/ed7a44d3-339b-431b-8662-81989727cab5
- Decision №22724/2/2024 (05.06.2024) — 269.7 was not in the first appeal, 302.3 — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/da472649-db45-4bcf-aff7-b703c96e1bbb
- Decision №25211/2/2025 (17.06.2025) — following order N 9105, 269.7 refused — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/dc2d95ec-b6f6-44c3-a1c3-176b0eb18bbf
Revenue Service (Dispute Resolution Council)
- Order N 33113 (27.12.2023) — fine and penalty interest lifted — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/f2f0c35a-e925-49ae-861a-5ea4b16b1ecf
- Order N 8875 (06.05.2025) — fine and penalty interest lifted — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/898c2393-7af1-45e9-95a8-c08d1f43b6cb
- Order N 11392 (25.05.2026) — fine and penalty interest lifted — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/83cd52d4-ff53-4545-bdda-0640970a0bca
- Order N 8905 (22.04.2026) — penalty interest lifted — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/14e0312d-a5ee-4b8e-9e22-a5b2d68bc4b6
- Order N 17 (08.01.2026) — only the fine lifted — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/634decd4-07bf-499c-ba41-15c3ceddafa3
- Order N 18784 (19.08.2026) — lifting of the "fine/penalty interest" was requested, only the fine lifted — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/92e6c643-89ee-4fa3-adf9-4d0d46c8ba38
- Order N 25354 (19.11.2025) — clerical error, fine lifted — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/c64f5412-803d-4c54-ae19-0efdeb2dd93e
- Order N 229 (12.01.2024) — financial situation, refused — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/ff346f42-e01c-4bcb-9480-959fc93c207f
- Order N 2208 (06.02.2024) — economic situation, refused — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/05c743ae-ae0d-412b-8054-1db0e9d9ece5
- Order N 9105 (07.05.2025) — financial situation, refused — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/8cb22f2f-e5a0-49d5-9a07-26683b52e19a
- Order N 3831 (19.02.2026) — refused; then №26854/2/2026 — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/d0136508-3982-4722-bc31-58baa90d4b81
- Order N 2284 (05.02.2026) — refused; then №26716/2/2026 — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/27d768f6-6c1d-434b-be16-b681f2fdc674
- Order N 3000 (12.02.2026) — refused; then №26756/2/2026 — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/18927b2e-0a89-44a4-9c2a-06c1e9ae2722
- Order N 2411 (06.02.2026) — refused; then №26826/2/2026 — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/5cd117b0-f0d3-4318-b74b-ae0ec50edbda
Courts
- Supreme Court decision №bs-222-219(k-14) (07.10.2014) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/1864d809-c2e0-4a90-8573-c8b925a8276a
- Kutaisi City Court decision N 3/871-18 (16.04.2025) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/cd4b8028-7ab5-480a-8b28-b9b80acea656
- Kutaisi City Court decision N 3/597-21 (16.05.2025) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/5d4effe3-188f-4324-8095-85aa310da589
- Supreme Court ruling N bs-991(k-25) (27.05.2026) — https://infohub.rs.ge/ka/workspace/document/83d3e214-4fc9-4b16-b200-de2b4558b3d3
Need tax, accounting or legal advice? 👉 Request a consultation — leave your number and we will get back to you.